He's just addressing the problem in a different way. By making the company more efficient. He can make up some of those lost calls each week. It's never bad to improve efficiency.
You are 100% correct in your assessment of what I'm doing.
As I've said, by being more efficient, I can clear up time for the Estimator. For instance, I had a specially made trailer for a piece of equipment for one of my guys who works on his own (his job is separate from the crews'). I paid $3,100 for it. Currently, every time he drives the piece of equipment off, or puts it back on, he loses ten to fifteen minutes making sure it is chained down correctly at different access points. If it's not chained down correctly, it goes flying, kills someone, and I get sued for a million bucks. Anyway, ten to fifteen minutes savings a day doesn't sound like much, but it saves him 1.5 to two hours a day. For the special made trailer, it pops on with just a "click" and that's it, and there is less of a chance of the machine going flying off of the trailer and hitting someone.
The Estimator used to spend probably a day a week doing customer service and quality check ups. But since I'm saving two hours a day for this laborer, that adds up to a free day for him. This laborer (who has been here ten years and knows his shit about the ops) has taken on the customer service and quality check ups, as well as for hose breaks, the guys needing oil, or a piece of equipment needs to be taken into be repaired.
So I free up time for the Estimator by making someone else more efficient, and by using the time savings.
It's like having two Estimators one day a week, for no extra pay.The $3,100 investment will pay itself off soon. And in general, being more efficient is good. We just bid a commercial job for 80k, and if we get it, the bottleneck would be the laborers, and dare I say it, the equipment.
The more Lyrical speaks, the more I would just go slap 100,000 infront of his biggest competitors estimator.
If it's that hard to get a new estimator, why not just eliminate your competition by buying theirs basically? If estimators are so hard to come by, just cripple your competition.
Because in most companies, the owner doesn't trust anyone else to do his estimates, so the owner is his own sole Estimator. This is for fear of them being inaccurate, or them stealing sidejobs. Some Estimators have been known for bidding against the company they are with, and either doing the jobs themselves or selling them to other companies. So, in 95% of the companies, the owner does the bidding, and everyone else works, and God help them if the owner gets sick and can't run bids. In five years, I've seen two companies that had Estimators, and neither of them were worth a damn. One guy had an recent arrest record for domestic abuse and drugs. The other guy had an attitude problem and thought he was better than everyone else. He smashed a customer's roof open on a job, and when the Crew Leader warned him he was doing it wrong, he stormed off when asked about it. I guess he ran the company he was at, and couldn't handled not being the Manager, Lead Estimator or Crew Leader.
Like I said, if the guy I'm talking to interviews well, based on him working with my Manager in the past at other companies, I'll offer him $1,500 more a month to leave where he is at.