Played the first scenario of Gloomhaven on Sunday. It took us like 5 hours, four players. There was a lot of distractions (someone would get a 10 minute phone call they had to take, followed by someone needing to use the bathroom as soon as the first guy got back, and then someone going to grab another drink, etc.) but the biggest slowdown was people choosing which cards to play. We would do a turn, and then sit in silence for 10 minutes while deciding the next turn.
On top of that, one guy got really annoyed with the secret initiatives and turns. To the point where he just went "Ok, well I'm going at 8 initiative, I'm charging into that next room and AOE stunning as many guys as I can. Thats' my plan." I think the other 3 of us at the table just kind of shrugged and kept doing our thing. The same guy made a big deal about no trading items or gold too, but I was like "Thems the rules and what the game is balanced around,. its not that big a deal." To which he replied "Meh, its stupid."
So... yeah...
Had a good time overall, super curious to get into the whole story and everything, I'm probably the only person out of the 4 who enjoys rules though, so the combat is probably just going to be more transparent and everyone else will be fine with that.
Super glad this friend wasn't one I asked to play Kingdom Death with though, I highly suspected it would be a bad fit, and after seeing him get pissy with Gloomhaven... yeah, think he would flip the god damned table over KDM.