Because, traffic is split and we may lose a bunch of historic threads (johnny's whore mongering, gravy's thread, etc..). The only reason posting is so heavy on the other site is not because everyone has moved. It's because a large part of it is due to so many people re-starting threads and making a concerted effort to post. The userbase is still split up right now. It seems that Craig might be a reasonable person and we could have simply waited, bought this site and let a_skeleton_03 set this one up exactly the same way. I don't know if he's been in contact with a_skeleton_03 yet or not, I'd imagine this isn't an emergency level priority for him like it is for us.
No one is saying the other site isn't great and that having it setup wasn't a good idea. No one thinks Draegan was right to sell it. Just that people over-reacted and jumped the gun a bit. I don't see what the harm would have been in simply getting word out about the backup site and waiting a week before trying to create an exodus.
That does remind me though, assuming a_skeleton_03 and co. can buy this domain and database back, can the content on the new site be merged with this? Or, would it be simpler to just archive all this content in a sub forum?