For me, hands down, Evolve wins E3. I sat at that booth for over an hour watching those guys play matches. That game is really great and is really piling up the awards.
I absolutely LOVED the art style on Valiant Hearts: The Great War, a sleeper IMO.
The Evil Within and The Hunt were both fantastic games .
I got to play Alien: Isolation on the console which was incredible. This game is amazing, but where it really, really shined was on Occulus. This game on Occulus was downright terrifying and awesome at the same time. I was sooooo glad I didn't get the Valkyrie demo (which I hear was great) or the Mario demo when I got in that room. What was great was on the concole version, when you take out the motion tracker, it takes your focus, but on the Occulus version, when you popped out the motion tracker, it was down to my left in my hand, so I can watch it with my peripheral or glance at it, but keep my focus on watching for the Alien. This game is 100% about evasion, stealth and survival. Wonderful game for Occulus.
I tried Sonys Morpheus. That was decent, but I got the not so great demo. I think the better demo for Morpheus was Valkyrie or the Shark Cage. I got the street luge. While cool, the resolution was not as good as Occulus v.2. There was some slight motion sickness after playing for a bit but that was due to the game style I believe, and having to move your head to move. It was a controller less demo.
About Destiny, it wasn't terrible, it just didnt wow me. I think with all the hype, it just turned out to be a good game, but not something I played and immediately said take my money. In that sense, it disappointed me. It's a good shooter. I'll play it, but eventually.
Evolve was by far the best. Alien Isolation on Occulus, was beyond anything I ever experienced, but I despair as who knows when/if that will be something we will have in our homes.