The "dead weight" shit is every guild. And it's probably true, but never to the extent the people complain about it. This is EQ. What are you going to do? Have your 10 "good" players start boxing 2 more boxes each and start sucking shit at raids to replace 20 people who do marginally? That's fucking stupid. Every guild has "bads" "average" "above average" and a healthy amount of "everyone else is bad (but really I am average)". Shit irks me so fucking hard having people who don't parse high for their class but show up and help others in guild versus dicklords who go balls deep on bosses, pull aggro and die, and then blame everyone else. Yeah, I'd rather have 44 year old Dayjob Danny who doesn't parse but doesn't constantly fuck up trying to burn brighter than everyone else.
The BEST is when these people try to do content in their "elite" groups outside of raid times and end up sucking shit, getting buttmad at each other, and quitting or gquitting because of their own egos. Happens every guild, every server.