Why are you unpleased with NIN? Curious as a fellow 60 NIN.
I'm a bit interested in MNK myself simply because my latency is messing up my mudra spam even with the GPN. It feels like NIN was made for Japanese players who benefit from having the best latency.
Also, as someone who just leveled 2 classes from 40-51 in north than, and now another from 50-55 purely on nthan fates, I feel your pain.
Yeah, what makes you disappointed with ninjas at max level?
I don't think they got the utility they needed to stay relevant for cutting-edge progression. My initial thought while playing one at E3 was that their damage was gonna be too low, but having played one at home now I really don't feel like that is the case; their damage is on-par with MNK. I was hoping they would've gotten a new debuff, but sadly, they didn't, so now it seems like they are harder to fit into a cutting-edge raid comp.
Assuming that we will need an INT debuff in the party (as we have for every other tier of raiding,) that means every raid group will need either a DRK or a MNK. If your raid group runs a DRK, then you can go DRG/NIN and be fine, but my static's PLD refuses to switch to DRK, so we have to put a MNK in the party. Even if it wasn't me, that last melee spot would be open to either DRG or NIN, and considering that BRDs are having a tough time dealing decent DPS without the DRG's piercing debuff (and DRG damage is fantastic right now anyways), there isn't really room for NIN.
Furthermore, if your static doesn't run a WAR, then NIN is even more screwed, because it is extremely difficult to use Aeolian Edge with Armor Crush thrown into the mix if you need to keep up Dancing Edge. So really, for a cutting-edge progression group, a NIN can only fit into a raid comp that has both a DRK and a WAR in it.
Of course, if you're not worried about cutting-edge progression, then none of this matters.
Any thoughts on Dragoons in the new expansion? Leveling one to go with my two tanks.
DRG will probably be the most-desired DPS in HW raiding. Top damage, piercing debuffs for BRDs (and MCHs if you are ever unfortunate enough to have one in your party), and Battle Litany is just icing on the cake.