Asmadai
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- 3,241
- 9,360
Asmadai -- How are Summoner, Scholar, Black Mage, White Mage, Paladin and Samurai any different from how Judge would go in terms of "lots of them running around", especially for Paladin, which was nearly an exclusive club, and White Mage, which is typically restricted to just the Padjal for instruction?
Judges were only ever mentioned in FFXII - and the peon version of them didn't even use Gunblades; how many of the Judge Magisters did? I know it wasn't all of them, either. The Garlean Legati we have seen over the years are clearly meant to be the homage to the Judges from FFXII. I don't expect there to be another, especially one where they just take the name and force it to fit as the name of a job, because lol FFXII.
Besides, it's a stretch to even consider Judge as a "job" in itself. It's unique to Ivalice and it's spinoffs, and not close to being something universal enough from the franchise to name a job in FFXIV. This whole call for there to be a Judge job has been going on in this game since Heavensward as far as I can remember, and honest to God i've never understood where it came from.
People have mentioned the possibility of it being called "Soldier" which is really only marginally more universal of a franchise term than Judge, but if they go the uncreative route it's a generic enough term to work. It may have only been an actual job in one or two games, but the term itself has been thrown around for years so it wouldn't be as odd as Judge would. But hell, Yoshi has mentioned before that he does want to eventually create a completely unique to FFXIV job, so maybe this is his chance. We don't exactly have much to go on for any sort of Gunblade wielder.