GoT - Is Over, Post Your Drogon Sightings
- Thread starter Araxen
- Start date
-
Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!
Go here and give us your nominations!Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!
Lenas
Trump's Staff
- 7,559
- 2,299
By what reasoning? Melisandre believes Stannis is the rightful king by Westerosi law and chosen by the Lord of Light. She has no motive to betray him, Gendry certainly doesn't have more right to the throne than Stannis does.
Siliconemelons
Naxxramas 1.0 Raider
- 11,871
- 17,836
Yes. Then Stannis sent an email to everyone important in the 7 kingdoms about it, which is how the "rumor" is public knowledge, at least among the big players in the realm.
oh really based on Melisandre having a slight dishonest quality, maybe power hungry? Beyond that.. consider if she believes Stannis to be the heir, his royal blood may be more powerful than gendry's to suit her needs.
Chukzombi
Millie's Staff Member
- 72,975
- 214,258
how is Mel dishonest? because she was fucking with gendry? she just got through explaining very honestly about how you dont let lambs see the knife. gendry is nothing to her except as a pawn to further Stannis. she has it in her head that stannis is the one true king and as far as i can tell from the show is extremely loyal to him.
Szlia
Member
- 6,629
- 1,375
It's half the story though. Joffrey's lineage is just a good pretext to try and overthrow him and put Stannis' mind at ease (I am not being power hungry, I am being righteous! I only want the throne because I am its legitimate owner!). In the end, the King is the guy that can be and stay King, no more, no less. No one will rebel over bad lineage other than those with a better lineage (Gendry and Stannis who are not in a position to do much - at least through conventional means) and those looking for an excuse to rebel (Greyjoy). The Stark are allied with the Tully and are no friend of the Lannister, but their issue is not Joffrey's lineage, it's the death of Ned and the capture of Sansa and Aria, two things that are on Joffrey. So if you punish Joffrey (PK Offline Lineage style?) for his crime against the Stark the situation becomes a lot easier to manage: it leaves just Greyjoy and Stannis being assholes.
Szlia
Member
- 6,629
- 1,375
She said something like 'I killed a lot of lambs, not one ever saw the blade' that was so ominous it was not possible for Stannis to not think 'Wait a second here? Am I a lamb too?'
yea, I really don't understand how anybody could trust Melisandre. She's more power hungry than Cersei, Talista and Maergarie combined.
moonarchia
The Scientific Shitlord
- 23,452
- 42,653
If the lambs got the same treatment Gendry got, it's small wonder they never saw the dagger coming. They were passed out.
Lenas
Trump's Staff
- 7,559
- 2,299
I wouldn't call Dany power-hungry at all. Dany is on a quest to get what she feels she is owed, something that was taken from her family, and is trying to do so somewhat honorably (like by freeing slaves).
Cersei wants power just to have it, and probably wouldn't care at the end of the day if she had to slaughter her own family for it.
Cersei wants power just to have it, and probably wouldn't care at the end of the day if she had to slaughter her own family for it.
Siliconemelons
Naxxramas 1.0 Raider
- 11,871
- 17,836
Dany I feel it is more of a restoration of her house and family than a pure power grab.
also ever since melasandras first drinking of poison thing where her necklace gem glimmers momentarily I have always kept an eye on it... I don't know if its nothing or just lighting or what...but it seemed dim until she started doing magic with the leeches.
why is there no episode sunday?!? Arr!
also ever since melasandras first drinking of poison thing where her necklace gem glimmers momentarily I have always kept an eye on it... I don't know if its nothing or just lighting or what...but it seemed dim until she started doing magic with the leeches.
why is there no episode sunday?!? Arr!
Proper claim to the throne is important, as it sways people to your side. The problem is that it isn't something that can really be proven without DNA tests.
There was a brief window after Robert died for the Starks, Baratheons, Tyrells and Tullys to unite against Joffrey and the Lannisters behind the proper king Stannis (or if he could be convinced to abdicate, Renly), which would probably get the Martells and Arryns motivated enough to join in as well. There would be a short war, a bunch of dead Lannisters and the Seven Kingdoms would probably be back in one piece within a year.
Instead they all kind of went their own directions and the Lannisters, wielding the power of King's Landing has been taking them out piecemeal, more or less. A lot of people oppose Joffrey's rule and question his claim, but they lost the chance to stand united and Tywin Lannister has been masterfully bludgeoning them all with his giant iron cock for the failure and making sure the chance doesn't come up again.
There was a brief window after Robert died for the Starks, Baratheons, Tyrells and Tullys to unite against Joffrey and the Lannisters behind the proper king Stannis (or if he could be convinced to abdicate, Renly), which would probably get the Martells and Arryns motivated enough to join in as well. There would be a short war, a bunch of dead Lannisters and the Seven Kingdoms would probably be back in one piece within a year.
Instead they all kind of went their own directions and the Lannisters, wielding the power of King's Landing has been taking them out piecemeal, more or less. A lot of people oppose Joffrey's rule and question his claim, but they lost the chance to stand united and Tywin Lannister has been masterfully bludgeoning them all with his giant iron cock for the failure and making sure the chance doesn't come up again.