Feanor
Karazhan Raider
- 7,766
- 35,304
GoT - Is Over, Post Your Drogon Sightings
- Thread starter Araxen
- Start date
-
Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!
Go here and give us your nominations!Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!
Spoilerish question but what amount of time are the novels as a whole supposed to cover anyways?
I think by the time we're at in the TV series, it has been about a year since King Robert and company came to Winterfell. Keep in mind that seasons are super long, so years are just counted by days and shit.
- 17,713
- 8,754
Question:
Should Berric Dondarrion be with the Brotherhood of Banners by this point (if strictly following the books) and would he already be in zombie mode? Has an actor even been cast for Dondarrion for season 3?
He featured briefly in Season 1 when Ned instructed him to leave Kings Landing and bring The Mountain to justice but that actor could well have been a "filler" casting decision
Should Berric Dondarrion be with the Brotherhood of Banners by this point (if strictly following the books) and would he already be in zombie mode? Has an actor even been cast for Dondarrion for season 3?
He featured briefly in Season 1 when Ned instructed him to leave Kings Landing and bring The Mountain to justice but that actor could well have been a "filler" casting decision
Dondarrion should be there already, yes. His zombification would have happened while Gregor was scouring the Riverlands.
McCheese
SW: Sean, CW: Crone, GW: Wizardhawk
- 6,918
- 4,315
Thoros of Myr was a lot more badass than I imagined him. For whatever reason during my reading I got this picture of him in my head of being more of a blundering oaf. That said, I really liked the portrayal of him and Anguy. I'm eager to see more with the Brotherhood.
- 17,344
- 47,328
Lejina
(╯°□°）╯︵ ┻━┻
- 4,672
- 12,177
Thoros won the melee tournament with his flaming sword. While the mountain was killing his own horse and trying to murder the knight of flowers, Thoros was kicking everybodies asses in the actual skill at arms tournament. Thoros is one of the most underrated swordman in the book and he's certainly no oaf.
I think people got that idea because he loved to get shitfaced with Bobby B (or anyone else for that matter).
My impression when reading the books was he was a drunken oaf, or it least looked that way to everyone else before he joined the brotherhood. Actually I vaguely remember him admitting that at some point.
Tuco
I got Tuco'd!
- 47,388
- 80,836
That or there's more to her character than what we know in the books /shrug
haven't finished the books, so finding out Bran is a Warg was pretty awesome. Obviously was wondering how the dreams/visions/raven would tie into it all
Soygen
The Dirty Dozen For the Price of One
- 28,433
- 44,761
I think them playing up Shae more than the books is to give a stronger impact to her betrayal of Tyrion. You don't have an inner-monologue of Tyrion from the books, so while it's clear that Tyrion loves her on the show, making her seem smarter and more important kind of replaces all the obsessing that he does in his head.
reavor
I'm With HER ♀
- 5,159
- 17,843
I think they kind of botched the jaime vs brienne fight. as i remember the whole fight was supposed to highlight how utterly badass of a fighter jaime was, that despite being malnourished and capitive for months and having his hands restrained, he was still pushing her to her limit. in the episode he was just slapped around a bit, not really doing that much.
well, he did reveal some kind of plans to influence the power in the north by having sansa become queen to some relative of arryn. but it's not as apparent as what varys is doing.
Tuco
I got Tuco'd!
- 47,388
- 80,836
It's tough to say who is more cunning or effective since their true purposes haven't been revealed yet. Both are a little too obviously deceptive for me. Varys always brags about how he's spying on everyone all the time and Littlefinger is literally telling people not to trust him. It just seems like when you have people like Ned, Cercei, Tywin etc running the show the Pycelle strategy is a smarter idea. Being a man who is known to have many secrets and many strings attached to things and no tangible power or real consequences for being killed is a bad idea.
That aside, I have no idea what Varys' end goal is by killing Tywin. He can't think he'll get a better station by assassinating Tywin and paving the way for Aegon to capture things. And he can't think that it's better for the realm by letting it go to shit under Cersei. Tywin just about had everything on lockdown before he died.
That aside, I have no idea what Varys' end goal is by killing Tywin. He can't think he'll get a better station by assassinating Tywin and paving the way for Aegon to capture things. And he can't think that it's better for the realm by letting it go to shit under Cersei. Tywin just about had everything on lockdown before he died.
- 7,879
- 507
He's a disciple of the Red God... Hasn't the other Red priestess birthed the shadow-vagina monsters already?
Girl A asks girl what is that guy like.
Girl b says he is a monster.
Girl A goes in and flirts with monster>?
Girl b says he is a monster.
Girl A goes in and flirts with monster>?
Soygen
The Dirty Dozen For the Price of One
- 28,433
- 44,761
That's only if you believe that Varys was behind Tywin dying. I still don't buy that Tyrion was deceived into killing him, although Varys killing Kevan does make it a bit more plausible. I just want to believe that Tywin was a hypocrite and Tyrion exacted some sweet, sweet revenge.