Locithon said:
I seriously don"t understand Tad"s criticism. Didn"t they promise to give that presentation beforehand...and it turned out they weren"t far enough along to release ip info at the time?
Nope. We were very clear with Ten Ton Hammer, when they asked us to do a panel at NYC Comic Con, that we would not talk about the game. They wanted us to speak anyway, so we said we would talk about what it"s like to live through the first year of a startup dev studio. And that"s exactly what we did, in a presentation titled "Creating the Online Entertainment Experience: Year One."
Anyone who felt their time was wasted by watching the video of the panel didn"t read the title of it. If it was called "38 Studios Reveals New MMO" and all we did was talk about cakes, you"d have a point--but that wasn"t the case.
We"ve said over and over again that we aren"t going to talk about the game. Curt mentioned some months ago that we had thought of revealing the IP at this year"s Comic Con in San Diego, but we changed our minds. It just makes much more sense to talk about the IP when we can also talk about the game, since the latter is what drives the former.
Should we just lock ourselves in a bunker and not engage in interviews or conversation until that point? Arguably, but the reality is that Curt Schilling, Todd McFarlane, and R.A. Salvatore are all public figures who get attention whether they want it or not. Plus, we have a few team members who are active in the gaming community apart from what we do at 38. There simply isn"t any realistic way to completely go dark, which is why we keep saying over and over again that we are not going to talk about the game.
I don"t know how anybody can call this overhyping or pimping our product. We haven"t said *anything* about the game except in the vaguest of terms in press releases, and a few interviews where we"ve discussed some of the philosophies behind it. Trust me, we turn down far more requests for interviews than we actually give. We really do try to be as quiet as possible, but when someone calls us out it is likely that Curt is going to feel the need to respond, and I will feel the need to clarify. It"s a vicious cycle, and only you can stop it!
tad10 said:
Taking shit? You think that you"ve taken a lot of shit? Your perception of reality vis-a-vis shit taking is seriously distorted Mr. Schilling. You are a successful athlete and head of a company and have (as far as I know) always been quite successful. Generally people in your position are the ones that hand out shit -- such as your post above. The people who take shit are those who don"t have millions in the bank, who don"t have rabid screaming fans, who can"t start companies to follow their dreams.
Far be it from me to need to defend Curt, but your post above is so far off the mark that I have to say something out of a general sense of needing to correct the Internets.
If you think Curt doesn"t take shit for the things he says, you haven"t read the comments on his blog, any MLB message board, or any Red Sox forum. Pro athletes take far, FAR more shit than anyone in the games business, especially ones who put themselves in the public eye like Schilling. The stuff Yankees fans say about him makes ANYTHING said about Brad McQuaid sound like a nursery rhyme. Some of your other comments are fair, but thinking that Curt lives in some ivory tower where no mud can touch him is just simply incorrect. Don"t take my word for it: do five minutes of research.