I think GW2 held the mantle of "last, great hope" to dethrone WoW, which is why it was so polarizing. There really aren't any MMOs on the horizon that look like they are going to be able to do so, which I think becomes very discouraging for a lot of folks.
I certainly wasnt expecting it to dethrone WoW or anything, but I sure did expect it to last more than 1 month in my rotation.
It really blows my mind at just how bad the recent MMO releases have been. I played EQ for 4-5 years solid, then moved on to FF11 for a year or so, then stayed in WoW for the good part of Vanilla - Wrath. Each of those MMOs lasted quite awhile for me.
I really liked FF11 and was hoping 14 would be amazing. Bought a new comp, Eyefinity set up, top of the line graphics card....I was set.
Then it released with 3 zones, 5 quests, and about 10 total different mobs in the game. I had never played such a bad and incomplete AAA mmo in my life as that. So fast forward to SWToR. I liked the small bit of Galaxies I played, and had they just upgraded the graphics and removed the NGE from it, it would be a great game. Yet we all know how that turned out. 300million into the game, and not even background music, any fun pvp, lifeless zones, huge faction imbalance etc....
Then as GW2 came over the horizon, it was my last hope for something other than WoW.
I cant believe how fast that got boring. Entire game screams "bot me" If you want karma, stand in any DE area and spam 3, 3, 3, 3, 3, 3, 3,3 ,3, 3. Dungeons are awful, combat isnt fluid, the removal of the trinity was a failure, AH doesnt work, Dungeons have no loot other than /random garbage.
PvP could have been fun if you could see the enemy, as it is now its just an AE fest in the general area you "think" the enemy is. Week long battles result in most servers not even caring about a pvp battle after the first day.....unlimited xfers led to zero community and everyone hoping servers until they chose the winning one. GW2 pvp is a snoozefest. /attack wall..../attack another wall....oh wait look!!! /attack another wall. Half the classes are broken and inept with no change in sight...necros, elementalists...rangers....hell, any pet class is useless.
Now GW2 was the last hope for anything really coming over the horizon anytime in the near future, so basically its WoW or bust.
Elderscrolls looked just like WoW down to the UI, and have zero faith in EQNext with how abysmal EQ2 turned out, and the fact they are scrapped it now 2x and rebuilding yet again....effectively just wasting money and time, pretty much guranteeing it gets releashed half ass to meet the bean counters quota.
So what is left? Basically GW2 was the last hope remaining for the forseeable future.