Was thinking about doing hardwood floors in the living room kitchen, but the general contractor I was talking to was saying vinyl is probably better especially since the quality has improved over the last twenty years. Anyone got any experience and/or advice on vinyl vs hardwood floors?
A lot of factors to consider:
1) Cost - hardwood only comes in natural woods + whatever finishes. Some are
absurdlyexpensive. You can get better exotic styles for a lot cheaper with vinyl. Installation is more.
2) Longevity - hardwood will last a lifetime typically
butit will NOT be flawless. Wood dents/scrapes/cuts/warps/etc. That's part of the beauty. If you want uniformity forever, go faux.
3) Feel - hardwood feels solid. Vinyl installations typically do not. Floating floors have benefits but they feel different. THAT SAID, the newest styles of underlayment are absolutely amazing (if not pricey) in softening the most obvious issue which is sound.
4) Weight - depends on house construction, but it can be significant if you have really old, thin (by modern standards) floor joists or things like that.
5) Styles - check out things like Tecsun painted desert, I've seen a room done in this and it was amazing even if completely unnatural:
12mm Painted Desert
Vinyl is OK but honestly I think there are better looking laminates out there than a lot of vinyl planks. Stuff like handscraped dark walnut 8" planks that would cost a fortune in hardwood look amazing and are easily afforded in laminate. Of course laminate installation around compressors/water lines needs to be done properly or it will fuck up. In fact for most kitchens if you go laminate I'd silicone everything around the 'food prep' area at least. Vinyl doesn't have that problem being that it's just plastic.