Investing General Discussion

Furry

Email Loading Please Wait
<Gold Donor>
23,424
31,272
If you take SEPP withdrawals don't you have to continue those until you reach 59.5? You like that you could choose to buy a car and then have to continue withdrawing from your IRA at and pay taxes at whatever your current salary rate is until you reach 59.5?
I'd qualify taking SEPP as not smart in the majority of cases for people working, but it's there. If you are not working and have no plans to work until 60, then it may be smart for you, depending on your balance. Spreading income out over years is almost always a tax win.
 

Kiroy

Marine Biologist
<Bronze Donator>
35,864
105,199
I know we've discussed 401ks and other tax deffered accounts before but:

If your 401k plan is that bad, you guys may have a good case against them. Walmart was sued for having a shit 401k plan and were forced to rectify it.

having bad options for 401k sucks dick but it's probably not the best career advice to sue your employer over it

much better would be to get a group of like minded workmates to take the issue up the chain, all the more effective if your group is a bunch of critical employees.
 

Locnar

<Bronze Donator>
2,848
3,165
having bad options for 401k sucks dick but it's probably not the best career advice to sue your employer over it

much better would be to get a group of like minded workmates to take the issue up the chain, all the more effective if your group is a bunch of critical employees.

Yes of course, I don't mean he himself should crusade it. I'm saying courts have established that employers must offer a certain standard and also include some low-fee index type options. Walmart got their ass sued because they were using the 401k for their own bests interests instead of the employees. I'm just saying that employers can't just do anything they want with regards to them.
 

Borzak

Silver Baron of the Realm
26,571
35,354
Obvious answer is to get stuff started with your coworkers and let them cause a stir and tank their career with a lawsuit, sit back and profit.
 

Tarrant

<Prior Amod>
16,137
9,603
Gonna dump my Gamestop stock so hard once it drops to $55 after buying it for $4.

I may just break even for all the time they dicked me over on my trade-ins over the years.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user

Loser Araysar

Chief Russia Reporter. Stock Pals CEO. Head of AI.
<Gold Donor>
84,447
171,202
I know we've discussed 401ks and other tax deffered accounts before but:

If your 401k plan is that bad, you guys may have a good case against them. Walmart was sued for having a shit 401k plan and were forced to rectify it.

Araysar , you say you are in some plan that has 5 percent in bonds, then you posted a shitty yearly return. Why any of it in bonds? Does your 401k at least have a low fee S&P index fund? If not, they need to be sued.

About not having access to your money. MOST 401k's have decent 401k loan programs so you can access money quick and basically free (you pay the interest back to yourself).

Also, you don't have to wait until 65 to access your money without penalty, if you retire early you can start withdrawing early. I think starting at age 55. Your HSA money can be accessed for health (obviously) but then for any reason you want after 65.

Unlike what someone posted above, i'd prioritize:

-401k first (to take advantage of match, and also its more time restricted and dependent on your actual paychecks in the calender year so more a hassle to max)
-HSA second because its fantastic overall tax savings but you can add money to it to max it straight from your bank account, and you can do it up until like April the next year.
-RothIRA last, like the HSA you can contribute straight from personal funds and have until like Spring of the next year.

I'm like Sanrith, very frugal and try to be as efficient as I can. Luckily my employer has a good 401k and HSA plan and also allows me to self direct my 401k investments which i've recently begun to do and im up 20 percent so far this year (thanks spacs). But even if it did not allow me to self direct, I could not pass up on the tax savings. I would just consider my 401k/HSA as my "safe bet" money and go wild with what was left over in my non-retirement accounts to balance it. (which is what i've been doing actually).

Its not prudent to yolo your entire net worth anyways.

They give you some basic presets (aggressive, conservative, moderate) based on where you are in your retirement planning. Obviously the further away you are from your goals, the more aggressive the strategy is recommended.

I never really had a 401K before because I dropped out of corporate in my late 20s to start my own company which I ran till my mid 30s. I was too poor in my twenties to allocate money to 401K and didnt really start doing it until my later 30s when I pretty much paid all my debt off. Same reason why I got late on investing.

When I started socking money away into 401K I put it on autopilot based on these "recommended presets", which was "aggressive". Their version of aggressive is 95/5 stocks/bonds. There wasnt a lot of money when I started so it wasnt a big deal. Now there's some decent change in there and I'm more particular about what happens to it. I got it all in 1 ETF now which still kind of sucks, but it sucks the least out of all of them. I dont want to sue the company because I'm on good terms with the owners, they have already treated me generously in every other aspect of my employment, and there's a 50/50 chance they will let me relocate to Midwest, keep my job and work remotely in the near future.

Anyways, I just applied for a "personal loan" to pull some cash out that I can reinvest back into the market. We'll see if they approve it.
 
Last edited:

mkopec

<Gold Donor>
27,019
41,350
Withdraw and Take loan from 401 are tottaly different things. Usually for a withdraw without penalty you have to show some kind of hardship, or else you get 20% penalty+whatever your tax rate is. This is why when you need some cash for some emergency you should take out a loan, which you pay yourself back the principal and interest.
 

Furry

Email Loading Please Wait
<Gold Donor>
23,424
31,272
Gonna dump my Gamestop stock so hard once it drops to $55 after buying it for $4.

I may just break even for all the time they dicked me over on my trade-ins over the years.
I suspect there a couple people out there looking to dump stock next week.
 

Furry

Email Loading Please Wait
<Gold Donor>
23,424
31,272
Withdraw and Take loan from 401 are tottaly different things. Usually for a withdraw without penalty you have to show some kind of hardship, or else you get 20% penalty+whatever your tax rate is. This is why when you need some cash for some emergency you should take out a loan, which you pay yourself back the principal and interest.

Yea, withdrawing is almost always bad other than the no penalty exceptions. 401k loan isn't Ideal, but can work if you need it. I've never done it, but there's been a couple times where I was real close for a quality of life issue, and my next car will almost certainly be blasted away with a 401k loan when all the 0% ride is about to end.
 

Tarrant

<Prior Amod>
16,137
9,603
honestly, as long as I can sell it at $40 I'll be happy and I doubt it'll drop $20 in pre market. But I'll be watching and see what happens.
 

Sanrith Descartes

You have insufficient privileges to reply here.
<Gold Donor>
46,734
131,308
I agree with the others about withdrawing. That being said, the Cares act did away with the 10% withdrawal penalty. See if it is still in effect. Also be conscious that it will all count as income for tax purposes. This is why loan is almost always better. Take the max loan amount, invest it in the SPY, QQQ or some other vehicle and pay yourself back the 4% interest or whatever it is monthly while making the extra return.
 

Sanrith Descartes

You have insufficient privileges to reply here.
<Gold Donor>
46,734
131,308
honestly, as long as I can sell it at $40 I'll be happy and I doubt it'll drop $20 in pre market. But I'll be watching and see what happens.
Yeah, no way that can drop to $20 in the pre-market...

1611455036450.png
 

Loser Araysar

Chief Russia Reporter. Stock Pals CEO. Head of AI.
<Gold Donor>
84,447
171,202
I agree with the others about withdrawing. That being said, the Cares act did away with the 10% withdrawal penalty. See if it is still in effect. Also be conscious that it will all count as income for tax purposes. This is why loan is almost always better. Take the max loan amount, invest it in the SPY, QQQ or some other vehicle and pay yourself back the 4% interest or whatever it is monthly while making the extra return.

that went away on 12/31/2020

and yeah, thats what i ended up doing
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user

Borzak

Silver Baron of the Realm
26,571
35,354
I agree with the others about withdrawing. That being said, the Cares act did away with the 10% withdrawal penalty. See if it is still in effect. Also be conscious that it will all count as income for tax purposes. This is why loan is almost always better. Take the max loan amount, invest it in the SPY, QQQ or some other vehicle and pay yourself back the 4% interest or whatever it is monthly while making the extra return.

I haven't looked into it but someone else said they had to show an impact from the virus before they were eligible. I don't think it was "just anybody", of course that wouldn't be hard to do.
 

TJT

Mr. Poopybutthole
<Gold Donor>
44,084
115,440
I actually got involved with this at my company. The problem is the people in a company assigned to pick 401k programs know Jack shit about any of it. When we changed providers I made it mandatory that it include an option for a low cost S&P 500 fund. Low and behold it has one good option and that's the one it has.
When I was at GM selecting that shit for my 401k I just went for the closest approximate index funds they have (GM has all totally internal products that GM Finance created) with the lowest fees.

My current job has Vanguard S&P 500 Admiral in the 401k so I've just been focusing on that.
 
  • 2Like
Reactions: 1 users