MTG: Arena
- Thread starter Vaclav
- Start date
-
Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!
Go here and give us your nominations!Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!
Vaclav
Bronze Baronet of the Realm
- 12,650
- 877
Vaclav
Bronze Baronet of the Realm
- 12,650
- 877
Yea I was dubious myself until they posted their "team" that was part of it. Was something like 3 other companies helping, DWD was the one that gave me hope though, since I consider myself a fan of theirs. Both Elder Scrolls and Eternal are solid.
ES improves the Hearth stone formula and Eternal digitized MTG style well without shitting the bed.
Vaclav
Bronze Baronet of the Realm
- 12,650
- 877
Chris
Potato del Grande
- 19,685
- -10,572
MTG Arena look promising, I feel lke they can make the cards on the battlefeild bigger though. The paper art doesn't quite work for a limited size screen.
I signed up with my DCI number yesterday so hopefully they give beta invites to paper players like myself? I'd play the shit out of this.
I signed up with my DCI number yesterday so hopefully they give beta invites to paper players like myself? I'd play the shit out of this.
Enzee
Trakanon Raider
- 2,197
- 715
Once again, I'm gonna beg for an invite if anyone ends up getting one to give out. I missed the last time someone was giving them away, and I didn't get into the beta cause I haven't played live mtg or mtgo in the last year 
been on hearthstone/eternal instead, but I want into mtg arena more then anything.
been on hearthstone/eternal instead, but I want into mtg arena more then anything.
StJesuz
Graybeard Lurker
- 460
- 1,560
My impression of this game is that it will be just another in the yearly series of throw away MTG games with the sort of predatory monetization that EA can only (wet) dream of. They slap a 20-40$ price on it at launch and it goes free to play after 6 months or so. The real price is how much you'll have to spend in booster packs to build a decent deck for online play after they tease all the different mechanics that you won't be able to pull off with the free cards. Then in a year or so they launch the next version and you get to buy it all over again.
Am I wrong?
Am I wrong?
Vaclav
Bronze Baronet of the Realm
- 12,650
- 877
It's been heavily implied it's going to be more like a Hearthstone/Eternal/Elder Scrolls style model - but monetization hasn't been heavily discussed yet besides vague terms.
Vaclav
Bronze Baronet of the Realm
- 12,650
- 877
Why can't the FOH cabal get us keys? Come onBraen walk in and ask for the forum tomorrow. Tell them its for a bunch of internet OG's.
Braen
is working with Wizards Digital? And either which way, I'd love to be added to a list of beggars on the topic as well. If there's guilds on there, we could even get Mistwalkers rolling on there. [Watch me have misremembered the FoH guildtag he did...]
Mr Creed
Too old for this shit
- 2,391
- 285
That has been heavily implied the last time, too. You don't bring in the dough on a MTG game using the Hearthstone model if you state upfront that you are going to stop releasing new sets within 2 years (aka Magic duels).
I was really itching for an online MTG game in the vein of Hearthstone back in 2015, and thus really interested in Magic duels *before* it came out. But after watching MTGO get one terrible new version after another for over a decade, I refrained from getting into Magic Duels when it finally came out because the early warning signs were there. I guess that was the right choice. I'm going to watch development on this, but I'm sceptical. With WotC digital products you have to be, no matter how much they promise.
ronne
Nǐ hǎo, yǒu jīn zi ma?
- 8,348
- 7,988
Magic duels was also not actually real magic. It had super limited sets, and preventing you from building fully custom decks etc. It was like buying a starter deck and only being able to change out 30 cards.
No idea how fair or whatever their monetization plan for Arena is going to be. Current beta is 72 packs of Ixalan to play constructed with, and there's no crafting/disenchanting system in place yet so it's basically just an alpha/functionality test and not much else. The only hint there is is there's a button in the store to buy packs for 1000 coins, but it doesn't work. Currently matches look to pay out 50 gold per, win or lose, with quests that pay 150.
The only interesting thing is the redeem codes section, which looks to be set up to support codes and QR scanning from presumably physical product and FNM or whatever rewards.
No idea how fair or whatever their monetization plan for Arena is going to be. Current beta is 72 packs of Ixalan to play constructed with, and there's no crafting/disenchanting system in place yet so it's basically just an alpha/functionality test and not much else. The only hint there is is there's a button in the store to buy packs for 1000 coins, but it doesn't work. Currently matches look to pay out 50 gold per, win or lose, with quests that pay 150.
The only interesting thing is the redeem codes section, which looks to be set up to support codes and QR scanning from presumably physical product and FNM or whatever rewards.
MrHolland420
KRA! KRA!
- 942
- 1,186
Zaphid
Trakanon Raider
- 5,862
- 294
I got an email with the key and a message that it's in open beta.
Then 3 games in, autoresolve sacrificed my creature and used that to kill an artifact on the board, which was mine, without asking. This is gonna need some work, because otherwise just passing all the phases of the opponents turn when nothing is happening will put me to sleep. The board UI is pretty cluttered, lands are pretty and all, but maybe just replace them with symbols ? And not even a basic MtG tutorials is definitely not going to win them new players.
Unless you are have a real MtG crush, Eternal is ATM the superior game, even if niche.
Then 3 games in, autoresolve sacrificed my creature and used that to kill an artifact on the board, which was mine, without asking. This is gonna need some work, because otherwise just passing all the phases of the opponents turn when nothing is happening will put me to sleep. The board UI is pretty cluttered, lands are pretty and all, but maybe just replace them with symbols ? And not even a basic MtG tutorials is definitely not going to win them new players.
Unless you are have a real MtG crush, Eternal is ATM the superior game, even if niche.
