Sterling
El Presidente
- 13,092
- 8,067
that's fair, i just think they're different enough that I can enjoy both.
MTG thread
- Thread starter brekk
- Start date
-
Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!
Go here and give us your nominations!Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!
Kuro
Naxxramas 1.0 Raider
- 8,932
- 23,485
I love draft too. Pressures different skills. Sealed leans much more heavily on tempo awareness (due to an overall weaker deck cohesion, tempo mistakes are generally punished much harder) and deckbuilding skill than most formats. Draft is superficially similar, but draft deckbuilding is a significantly different beast, since you have a degree of control over what materials you will be using, which ups the power level of what's going on and requires a very different set of decision trees.
That's why Magic's the best card game, formats for whatever you want out of it.
That's why Magic's the best card game, formats for whatever you want out of it.
Sterling
El Presidente
- 13,092
- 8,067
2 pre releases, scrubbed out going in blind trying mardu knights,
next time went Green/black value with the clover & adventure stuff
managed to get an oko, 1 rider, buddy of mine got a goose/rider in his pre release pack, saw a bunch of the evo wilds2.0 card
next time went Green/black value with the clover & adventure stuff
managed to get an oko, 1 rider, buddy of mine got a goose/rider in his pre release pack, saw a bunch of the evo wilds2.0 card
Koushirou
Log Wizard
- 5,164
- 13,051
I generally try to play one prerelease each set just for something different than commander, which is the only format I actually play. I am fucking awful at sealed deck building and I get anxious playing 1v1 for some reason, which usually results in me making heinous amateur mistakes. I pulled a border less Oko in my sealed packs and of the two decks I made, had to splash for him. Twice I was able to cast Oko in a good position and twice I completely forgot I had something on the board that could generate the splash mana I needed. I’m not sure it would have won me those matches, but fuck it could have helped. I don’t mind losing in this type of format, but I get incredibly frustrated when I make multiple mistakes like that in the span of a couple games. Shit like that generally won’t make too big of a difference in EDH but it feels like a goddamn death sentence in a 1v1.
As far as deckbuilding for sealed goes, I follow the bread rule, but in most of the events I’ve done, I either pull no bombs or pull a bomb with nothing to support it, and I don’t think I’ve had an event yet where I pulled a decent amount of removal. What do you look for instead when that happens? This event, my only bomb (other than Oko who never hit the field) was a LockMere serpent out of my whole pull. I tried to build a blue/black mill deck around it with some of the mill/gy centric cards I had and it was an unmitigated disaster and I got trounced round 1 in less than 10 minutes from a red/white aggro deck. I had made a green/white semi food/tokens deck with my leftover shit, the goose being the only good thing in it, and at least that deck did shit, but just had no oomph to it. Second round I played a guy with his daughter piloting a spectacular golari deck. Questing beast, love struck beast, once upon a time, the ramping adventure giant, preserver, and plenty of removal to back it up. Hell of a pull for that guy though he apparently got spanked round one. Wonder wtf deck did that to him.
As far as deckbuilding for sealed goes, I follow the bread rule, but in most of the events I’ve done, I either pull no bombs or pull a bomb with nothing to support it, and I don’t think I’ve had an event yet where I pulled a decent amount of removal. What do you look for instead when that happens? This event, my only bomb (other than Oko who never hit the field) was a LockMere serpent out of my whole pull. I tried to build a blue/black mill deck around it with some of the mill/gy centric cards I had and it was an unmitigated disaster and I got trounced round 1 in less than 10 minutes from a red/white aggro deck. I had made a green/white semi food/tokens deck with my leftover shit, the goose being the only good thing in it, and at least that deck did shit, but just had no oomph to it. Second round I played a guy with his daughter piloting a spectacular golari deck. Questing beast, love struck beast, once upon a time, the ramping adventure giant, preserver, and plenty of removal to back it up. Hell of a pull for that guy though he apparently got spanked round one. Wonder wtf deck did that to him.
Vinen
God is dead
- 2,790
- 495
I got Golden Goose promo and Robber of the Rich. Traded away my Golden Goose promo for a Wildborn Preserver promo. Not really a fair trade (favors him) but he was excited about the card and I'm sure I'll get a playset of them when I crack open a case of Eldraine in a month or two. Don't really care about it being a promo.
Robber of the Rich was hillarious during the 2 games where I was able to pop it off early. Stole so many good cards.
Unless you are a store why in God's green earth would you open a case of ANY magic set? That's like literally throwing money in the trash.
- 1
Punko
Macho Ma'am
- 8,006
- 12,832
I came back to MTG about 1 year before Modern Masters was released, and spent over 3k$ on boxes. I got them at € 175 / box.
My only regret is not spending more.
Not all sets are bad, but realistically, 98% is.
On the other hand I don't think I'll ever recover 70% of what I invested in expedition fetches, but at least they look nice.
No idea why they never went up in price, I'm considering that there is a significant amount of fakes in rotation.
Vinen
God is dead
- 2,790
- 495
I enjoy it and have the money to do it? I don't disagree its not throwing money in the trash.
I'll probably pay ~80 USD shipped per box.
Hey as long as you acknowledge it's a retarded waste of time and money you do you.
Vinen
God is dead
- 2,790
- 495
Rudy (Alpha Investments) sells them for 80 USD / box shipped to Patrons.
Here is the real waste of money. My 2 boxes were the first opened on his channel.
- 1
Sterling
El Presidente
- 13,092
- 8,067
Interesting. He sells boxes at cost because he makes money from other revenue streams, that's kind of cool. Nobody really makes money on boxes, mark up is dogshit even if you sell them for 110 or whatever from a retail standpoint.
Ukerric
Bearded Ape
- 8,311
- 10,287
That's an interesting choice of packaging. Let's see how many combos we have: standard borders/no borders alternate art/fancy border alternate art times foil/non-foil. 6 different cards to collect. For every rare/mythic.
He's right in those opening videos "it feels like sports cards".
Mahes
Bronze Baronet of the Realm
- 5,242
- 6,260
I actually think they would make good money on a super rare set. The problem is that the sets/cards always seem to go to the people who do not collect but rather just resale them at a premium. Using some sort of random lottery that only allows for one entry with some sort of confirmation that the person is not a computer bot and only in the United States might work. We could get a "Magic Transcendent Collection". Only 100 boxes available each going for $10,000(People would actually pay this). Run key cards that have been reprinted before but in super high quality, alternate art work with actual signatures from the artist. Each box includes one actual hand drawn piece of art work with detailed coloring by the artist. The card is playable and is also signed in a space at the bottom as to not disturb the art work. The card and artist are random and is never duplicated. The one card could even be lands which would instantly make them the most valuable single land in the history of the game. Try to get that collection.
Yep, I could see this happening.
Ukerric
Bearded Ape
- 8,311
- 10,287
