"The items were all no-trade! There wasn't any plat! The buffs don't last very long! We have the logs!"
Uh huh. And this confidence comes from where exactly. I hope the second round of horseshit was enough to convince them that they probably in fact did not have everything under control even the first time around and should probably just go with a wipe.
If they don't I look forward months from now hearing people still complain about how Bigogrecock from <Lords of Jizz> got a bunch of level 50 druid buffs, a dragoon dirk, and two bags of belts before the server went down and catapulted to an insurmountable lead and the first Nagafen kill and it was never ever fair. Oh, and Wankspank of <Elite Cockjockeys> totally put 1000 plat in the shared bank before servers went down and that's how he strangled the economy.