Pacific Rim
- Thread starter Fedor
- Start date
-
Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!
Go here and give us your nominations!Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!
holy shit....i did not connect the reactor fire burst with Mazinger breast heatray.....thanks dude. This movie it's even more an homage to the father of super robot genre than i thought
we just missed Boss Robot and Venus tit-missiles
thats the equivalent of a mutant woman with a dozen A-minus-munis cup tits....call me old fashion but i still prefer just 2 gigantic
...close enough.
Chukzombi
Millie's Staff Member
- 73,141
- 214,419
please let me know what your definition of campy is.
this is what i get from MW
http://www.webster-dictionary.org/definition/campy
this is what i get from MW
http://www.webster-dictionary.org/definition/campy
j00t
Silver Baronet of the Realm
- 7,380
- 7,477
well, maybe it's relative, but to me, camp is bruce campbell. legolas sliding down the stairs on a shield or an elephant's trunk wasn't camp. that was just a directorial choice to demonstrate his "elven grace." to me, camp is for humor and since i didn't see him doing those things for humor, i don't see it as camp.
and with the dwarf tossing moments... i mean i definately can see how you would see that as camp, after that definition... but at the same time that definition just seems... overly encompassing. i mean with that definition, what the difference between comic relief and camp? well, i can tell you that when i see it, i know it. but that's not really all that beneficial.
to me, comic relief is comedy used to relieve the tension of a serious moment, but doesn't otherwise detract from the scene. camp is comedy used to relieve the tension of a serious moment by letting the audience know that actors/directors/writers/whatever are not taking the material too seriously.
and after reading that, maybe i'm even too strict in that by assuming that camp = comedy... but either way, i don't see ANYTHING in LOTR as camp. however, the hobbit? pssh... yes. campy.
and with the dwarf tossing moments... i mean i definately can see how you would see that as camp, after that definition... but at the same time that definition just seems... overly encompassing. i mean with that definition, what the difference between comic relief and camp? well, i can tell you that when i see it, i know it. but that's not really all that beneficial.
to me, comic relief is comedy used to relieve the tension of a serious moment, but doesn't otherwise detract from the scene. camp is comedy used to relieve the tension of a serious moment by letting the audience know that actors/directors/writers/whatever are not taking the material too seriously.
and after reading that, maybe i'm even too strict in that by assuming that camp = comedy... but either way, i don't see ANYTHING in LOTR as camp. however, the hobbit? pssh... yes. campy.
Chukzombi
Millie's Staff Member
- 73,141
- 214,419
Peter jackson who directed dead alive and the frighteners before he did the lotr trilogy is not what I would call a serious director. Look im not putting the lotr trilogy down. I loved them actually, but yeah dude there is a large portion of silliness and camp in those films, which is why those films are classics.
j00t
Silver Baronet of the Realm
- 7,380
- 7,477
sam raimi was the executive producer for hercules, xena, and the evil dead series. those were all EXTREMELY campy. he also was the executive producer for spartacus, which is anything but. i mean i get what you're saying and i'm not trying to change your mind, if that is what you ACTUALLY think. i mean seriously, what do i care? it's just that your argument for WHY it's camp doesn't make any sense to me. bruce campbell is king of camp... but his character in burn notice isn't campy.
if you want to say that lotr is campy because it had some over the top silly moments, that's fine. i don't agree with you, but again, that's fine.
if you want to say that lotr is campy because it had some over the top silly moments, that's fine. i don't agree with you, but again, that's fine.
j00t
Silver Baronet of the Realm
- 7,380
- 7,477
back on topic... took the wife and in-laws to see this again earlier this week... while not QUITE as enjoyable the second time around... i'd still rate the movie as an absolute must-see for anyone enjoying fun, simple popcorn action movies. the ONLY scene that just... bothers me is when raliegh and mako are talking in his bunk for the first time. she's talking to him about what she thinks of him and how he's too headstrong or whatever... the dialogue isn't all that great but it's fine... even the deliveries are fine. there's a lot to be desired but again, robots vs monsters. there's about 20 seconds of screen time where i get just... so irritated that i want to look away and forget what i'm looking at. that 20 seconds or so of raliegh talking to mako with his head tilted 60 degrees just... omg.
i agree with joot. there's a big difference between comic relief and a movie being campy. i wouldn't consider any of the LOTR to be campy, even though they had scenes that i don't think should have been put in the movies (like some of the legolas scenes or the dwarf toss). mary and pippen provided comic relief, but where also serious in a lot of scenes (like when trying to fight to save boromir). i'll give you someone like C3PO in star wars, who is total camp, but i will counter that i think the star wars movies would have been even better if he wasn't even in them (or lucas didn't make him the only gay robot in movie history).
Caliane
Avatar of War Slayer
- 15,590
- 11,896
Its a fine line at times. others not so much.
I'd say Lotr does step over a few times.
Dwarf tossing.
Tricking Treebeard into going south.
Wormtongue in his entirety.
Pac Rim is inherently more campy, with the entire premise of giant robots and homaging anime. The very backbone of the movie is campy.
Rocket elbow, and such, are clearly in the camp field.
Charlie day and the other guy, as well as Hannibal Chau.
I'd say Lotr does step over a few times.
Dwarf tossing.
Tricking Treebeard into going south.
Wormtongue in his entirety.
Pac Rim is inherently more campy, with the entire premise of giant robots and homaging anime. The very backbone of the movie is campy.
Rocket elbow, and such, are clearly in the camp field.
Charlie day and the other guy, as well as Hannibal Chau.
