Pan'Theon: Rise' of th'e Fal'Len - #1 Thread in MMO

  • Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!



    Go here and give us your nominations!
    Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!

Adebisi

Clump of Cells
<Silver Donator>
27,713
32,825
So from what I gathered:
People who pay for forum access have amazing MMO ideas
No trolls would ever pay to join a forum
 

shabushabu

Molten Core Raider
1,408
185
So from what I gathered:
People who pay for forum access have amazing MMO ideas
No trolls would ever pay to join a forum
Dollars committed means commitment in some form.. if you are paying monthly you really want to be involved which are the types of people they need at this point. It is not the worst idea to keep out the majority of main-stream MMO players for which their idea is NOT targeted.

I still think they need a solid go to market and I have not seen it...

@Brad if you still lurk, take a look at shadowrun and what they did. They released an RPG with their mechanics and then are going for Shadowrun online. Maybe 2 steps gets you there rather than 1 and the first step is a game people could get behind not just an alpha that would be shopped for more MMO funding dollars which in this market will likely lead to the mainstream ideas those with the dollars are paying for.
 

Melvin

Blackwing Lair Raider
1,399
1,168
What the fuck is that even? Just click the female button and pretend you have a sausage between your legs for god sake. Or are they really asking for the option to be able to make an ugly as sin woman?
I think what they're really asking for is an official stance from the dev team saying that it's a-okay to make a public nuisance, or at least a spectacle, of their gender and sexuality. I really don't like the way the OP hid the transgender question behind a facade of "adult themes" in general. (Unless he's trolling; in that case, nicely done.) It's one thing to be able to cyber your harem of Ogre manginas in private, but some people prefer Second Life's permissive and nature.

Ugh, I started typing up a serious opinion about this, but I just can't believe that OP isn't trolling.
 

pharmakos

soʞɐɯɹɐɥd
<Bronze Donator>
16,305
-2,234
What the fuck is that even? Just click the female button and pretend you have a sausage between your legs for god sake. Or are they really asking for the option to be able to make an ugly as sin woman?
hey now

trannies are a long standing tradition around here
 

Adebisi

Clump of Cells
<Silver Donator>
27,713
32,825
They should just have the option to customize the size of your bulge regardless of gender selection.
 

Mr Creed

Too old for this shit
2,385
277
So you think it would turn out ok because after spending thousands of man hours designing a quest based WoW game people would just abandon it in favor of grinding mobs like EQ because the idea of a group based WoW questing clone fails so hard that players are forced to just flat abandoned most of the quest based leveling.

Kinda begs the question of why you would bother with the quests at all in that case, doesn't it? Which was kinda my entire point, the only viable option they gave was the EQ option because the other options are unworkable for a group based game or they lack the resources to make that type of game or both.
Yea it sounds ok to me - it could shit the bed or be great, depends on whether they deliver a quality experience or not. That is independent from your question, which really is "do they have the resources to actually make that?" - the answer to your question is obviously no, because their resources are good for maybe 3 months of work. And before we even get to your question there is the 'does their team have the skills to make a working MMO' which is probably also a No.

If you just focus on the question, which experience would be desirable, I dont see a big issue with making a quest game that has alot of group content which you then market to a grouping-interested audience. Obviously not a carbon copy of WoW because that's solo focused. Simples changes like quest shit drops for everyone and quests are sharable out of order, and to the xp ratio of quests vs kills would remove most of the issues, and that's applying 2004 logic for Vanilla WoW. Someone considering these issues in 2014-17 should create much better solutions - which is brings us back to 'has the team the competence and the money?'. Nope, so we're only theorycrafting.
 

Vandyn

Blackwing Lair Raider
3,656
1,382
He says that despite there only being 3k backers on the KS, it shows many more would subscribe to this game once it's out and he wants to build community with everyone that would be interested in this, yet limits that community to only people that are willing to donate to his game. Then throws out the 'we don't have manpower to moderate forums' excuse. I just don't get his argument, he acknowledges there is a bigger crowd that would play this game, but chooses to shut that crowd out on any feedback they may give. Just say you're in desperate need of money since you obviously are at the bottom floor of development. In fact you're probably not even in development.
 
They should just have the option to customize the size of your bulge regardless of gender selection.
Hey, boob-slider for women previously in *how many* games? A codpiece slider is certainly fair in that sense. It should also max out at "elephantitis."

Have boob and junk sliders for both genders. Equality!

Also, facial and body hair sliders for both... amirite?!?

(But seriously, coming from someone who would've likely been a TS if I were younger and had more money, keep the traditional genders. That's what RP guilds and Goldshire on Moon Guard are for)
 

TragedyAnn_sl

shitlord
222
1
Did he really say this?
It was my interpretation. But he said"We can't overly worry about upsetting a person on the forum who one minute was a big Pantheon fan, but then, in the next, a hater because they don't feel listened to, or felt that while we were technically listening, we really were not truly listening because we didn't simply agree with them and promise to include a feature or two that has been dear to them for years. "
In my OPINION, that describes most of the posters in this thread (and the original Pantheon thread). I wouldn't say I'm a hater, but I definitely went from swallowing Brad's frank n' beans to being a skeptic. I still WANT this game. I WANT them to succeed, but I am skeptical of... a lot of things surrounding this project at this point. But...I want to believe and I keep waiting for them to convince me. I guess that's not their job, though... Oh...wait...Hm...

With that being said, I just saw Todd McFarlane tweet this (pretty sure he did this "pro bono") and again, every artist I know is constantly doodling and sketching. Where are the freaking Pantheon sketches!!
rrr_img_61695.jpg
 

Merlin_sl

shitlord
2,329
1
It was my interpretation. But he said"We can't overly worry about upsetting a person on the forum who one minute was a big Pantheon fan, but then, in the next, a hater because they don't feel listened to, or felt that while we were technically listening, we really were not truly listening because we didn't simply agree with them and promise to include a feature or two that has been dear to them for years. "
In my OPINION, that describes most of the posters in this thread (and the original Pantheon thread). I wouldn't say I'm a hater, but I definitely went from swallowing Brad's frank n' beans to being a skeptic. I still WANT this game. I WANT them to succeed, but I am skeptical of... a lot of things surrounding this project at this point. But...I want to believe and I keep waiting for them to convince me. I guess that's not their job, though... Oh...wait...Hm...

With that being said, I just saw Todd McFarlane tweet this (pretty sure he did this "pro bono") and again, every artist I know is constantly doodling and sketching. Where are the freaking Pantheon sketches!!
rrr_img_61695.jpg
ROFL, 10 minutes. Yea cause HE HAS A PASSION FOR DRAWING. The only drawing the Pantheon team is willing to do is write their name on the back of the check at the bank to cash it.
 

TrollfaceDeux

Pronouns: zie/zhem/zer
<Bronze Donator>
19,577
3,743
you should post a real life pic of you two doing that.

preferably naked.

with your children in the background.