Pan'Theon: Rise' of th'e Fal'Len - #1 Thread in MMO

Dumar_sl

shitlord
3,712
4
District 9 is for the Trolls
If I have to start with all the other races, I'm making it a point to come back at max level and kill all the guards & NPCs.

rrr_img_57876.png
 

tad10

Elisha Dushku
5,534
601
I'm not even going to say you're wrong, but all I ever see are short term reports with stuff like "Revenue up 500%!" and "profits tripled!" Well, those numbers aren't all that impressive when you consider the games were on their last legs and probably weren't making much money. I mean, if you saw SOE say, "Vanguard players up 10000% since going f2P," you would have been skeptical as shit.

Either way, I think f2p has saved some games. It definitely did with SWTOR, which made something like 140 million in microtransactions last year if I'm remembering a recent article correctly.
Yep, SWTOR is making money from FTP but that's the Star Wars nerds.
 

Aeiouy_sl

shitlord
217
0
This thread is getting beyond ridiculous lol.. Why is it every time things start looking up, it's dragged back down with speculation and hypotheticals? Stay on topic people! Lol.. Anyway predictions on combat doc?
I'm not saying it's bad or good. I'm just saying that is literally what is happening. Pretending they have a plan is naive and actually just plain ignorant.
Why? Because Ben said they had already shared all the assets they had? This has nothing to do with them having fleshed out general classes and sub classes

Some of you have miraculously low threshold for comprehension. I realize some people think being close minded and hateful somehow makes one look like they are just challenging and being hard nosed.
Dummies like beercube or whatever said they did not even think about multi paths until they put the crusader up, which is provably wrong.

It is absolutely false that they decided to create multiple paths for classes only when they came up with the crusader.

It would probably serve everyone well to focus your complaining on real things and not on unfounded and essentially irrelevant conspiracies.
 

zzeris

The Real Benny Johnson
<Gold Donor>
21,264
93,041
Really, dude? You're going to turn it into an US vs. THEM thing? You really are just in here to hate, flame, and troll, aren't you?
The guy has had barely over 200 posts in this entire site. 64 posts have not been trolling this thread. 145 either negative posts or posts about other games on this thread. Not one single post in this thread before this could be considered a shit release. Of course he is trolling this thread. There were no early advocate posts. There was no early hope. He's a talentless hack that has said the same thing over and over for weeks and is hoping for anyone to listen to his shit. He's not even a good troll.

He sounds so much like Qwerty it's painful. What do you call a poster smarter than Qwerty and not as bright as Utnayan? Boozecube.
 

tad10

Elisha Dushku
5,534
601
I am glad we have tad10 here to post up opinions like fact, he posts them over and over it almost becomes true. Fucking as bad a UT imo. He has zero clue to how Vanguard did financially. Rickshaw this mouthbreather.
I think you mean medicate - you're not following the Amod thread.
 

Flc_sl

shitlord
121
0
I'm not even going to say you're wrong, but all I ever see are short term reports with stuff like "Revenue up 500%!" and "profits tripled!" Well, those numbers aren't all that impressive when you consider the games were on their last legs and probably weren't making much money.

Either way, I think f2p has saved some games. It definitely did with SWTOR, which made something like 140 million in microtransactions last year if I'm remembering a recent article correctly.
That's the thing. I absolutely believe that subscription CAN make more than free to play, obviously, but in order to do that you need a giant base of customers who thinks that your game is superior to the competition, since its only the rare gamer that will play two MMOs with subscriptions at the same time. Going free to play for these games was an acknowledgement that, A) their game wasn't as good or better than WoW, and thus didn't have the same level of player retention, and B) that something had to change in order to raise revenues.

It's quite possible that revenues are nowhere near what they were when the game first went free to play, but if these games had stayed subscription only they would have died long ago.

Tad seems to be arguing that it was free to play that killed these games. All I'm saying is that these games died long before they went free to play, and free to play slowed - rather than hastened - their descent.
 

Mr Creed

Too old for this shit
2,394
287
Give me a break, Convo. I know you really want this game to succeed, but I've read your posts and you're a smart guy - take off the McQuaid-colored goggles.

First, when it comes to clarity of vision, EQN is in a totally different ballpark than Pantheon. In fact, Brad should have looked hard at their SOE Live presentation and taken a page from that book. Regardless of what you think about the quality of EQN's design goals and ideas, they were presented brilliantly and in crystal-clear fashion. Ponytail came out and, with great passion, stated everything he and his team thought was wrong or underdeveloped with MMOs, translated those thoughts into "pillars" of how they wanted to evolve the genre (life of consequence, destructability, changing world, and evolving the core game) and then gave a specific example of each (emergent AI, voxels, rallying calls, and multi-classing/deck building/horizontal progression.)

The ironic thing is that Brad has always attempted to associate himself with being a visionary, but the thing is, there's no vision here. Or, best case scenario (and I don't know why we'd give him the benefit of the doubt by applying a best case scenario, but whatever), he's building the vision as he goes forward. All we heard in the beginning is he wanted something like EverQuest that had a lot of grouping. That was his pitch. And, oh yeah, he's Brad McQuaid.

This is far more than just a communication problem. This is a vision problem.

Imagine if he were pitching a sitcom. This is what it would be like:

"Hey guys, I'm writing a sitcom. It's going to be like Friends, but with a bit of Seinfeld."
"Ok, what's the plot?"
"..."
"Who are the characters?"
"Let me get back to you in 48 hours... (48 hours later) Ok, so there's a Ross and a Rachel, and a Chandler, but there's no Joey."
"But we love Joey, we really want a Joey character in the show. I'm not sure if we can give you money for this since there's no Joey."
"Just kidding guys, there IS a Joey. He's part of the Chandler character. See? Innovation! Vision!"

The way they handled the entire warrior/crusader thing is so indicative of the fact there hasn't been a vision at all. Someone with a vision sees complaints and says, "You know what, I hear you guys, but we made this decision because of X, Y, and Z." Or they might say, "You know everyone, our vision was X, Y, and Z, but you all make a good point. So we're going to find a way to incorporate warriors into that vision."

What they don't do is say, "Uhhh yeah... actually, that was part of our vision all along, guys! We just didn't reveal it yet! But here it is! Yeah! See, we're thinking really far ahead!"

And that's the issue. Not that they're adding things to the game as they go along. It's that they came into this with the fucking hubris that Brad's name alone would be enough to carry it, were totally unprepared, totally vision-less (from the guys who claim vision is everything), and are now pretending that their vision is far more concrete than it actually is (see: combat update) and hoping that everyone following them is too fucking stupid or naive to notice.

They're charlatans, preying on the nostalgia of their audience.
His blatant hate aside he has a point, that is exactly what they are doing. However at least they've picked up on the fact that they need to do it and are wrapping the brainstorming from the last months into some kind of design doc. Better late then never I suppose, they certainly paid for it in lost pledges. Also, Friends with no Joey would've tanked.


Brad.. NO CROSS SERVER PLAY. Have you NOT heard our cries for the last 10 years!

That's it. I'm making a KS. Come one and all to the high fantasy world of Dumaria.
I would fund/play that. I'm serious.


I get what you're saying, and it sounds romantic and appealing. It just isn't practical or good game design.
It is good world design though, which is important for some here (the minority I'm sure). That we dont even know about this question and discuss it on guesswork is caused by their lack of preparation. They have enough idea guys on the team that all the lore and design concept shit could've been in the KS on day 1.

I think all races living together in Happytown is too much of a sacrifice for a good world design. Placescape/Sigil has been referenced here, but Sigil is the Plane of Knowledge. We dont really want PoK or we could go with GW2 style waypoints right away. Which would be ok for a game, but sucks for a world. I think they said the first collisions that shaped the world as it is were centuries ago? Unless all races are just peachy living together one or the other would've moved out even if they sought refuge together. People here are yearning for EQ-style ogres and trolls, that includes roasting dorfs or eating them alive if you lack a fire. I doubt being in a different district is enough to keep races from going to war over that. End result, one side annihilated (no trolls for you!) or moved out and made their own town.
 

Lysis

N00b
102
0
There's no way a 5-10 Million dollar game requiring ongoing development, operations, facilities and customer service costs is getting post-KS funding for a projected 20-50K subs @ $60/copy and $15/month. Especially when that successful KS pre-sold 7K copies.

They don't have a business plan. Just a bunch of ideas and hot air.

I can already imagine Brad's response: "well, we're game designers, not MBAs"
 

jooka

marco esquandolas
<Bronze Donator>
15,400
6,670
I think you mean medicate - you're not following the Amod thread.
why would I follow another thread to post about the bullshit you post here? Are there some revelations there you aren't quoting here?
 

Aeiouy_sl

shitlord
217
0
This thread is getting beyond ridiculous lol.. Why is it every time things start looking up, it's dragged back down with speculation and hypotheticals? Stay on topic people! Lol.. Anyway predictions on combat doc?
Let's run an experiment. Everyone go to the Kickstarter forums and make hundreds of posts complaining about cross-server play. If they don't come out with an update in 72 hours "clarifying" the cross-server comments to not actually mean cross-server, I will make an entire thread dedicated to praising how brilliant Aeiouy is and how lucky I am to have read the posts that stem from his brilliant mind.
How about I just call you dumb and we leave it at that. You think they magically changed one of the crusader sub classes to warrior the night before release of the class because a few people complained about no warrior.

Why you think your position is more reasonable, sensible or logical than the alternative says a lot about you. But go ahead with your half assed experience.

Or just ask Brad if they planned for the warrior to be a sub class of the crusader. I can promise you I am not worried in the least.
 

Flc_sl

shitlord
121
0
How about I just call you dumb and we leave it at that. You think they magically changed one of the crusader sub classes to warrior the night before release of the class because a few people complained about no warrior.

Why you think your position is more reasonable, sensible or logical than the alternative says a lot about you. But go ahead with your half assed experience.

Or just ask Brad if they planned for the warrior to be a sub class of the crusader. I can promise you I am not worried in the least.
Let me apologize, because you actually impress me. I'm simply amazed you can type with both hands wrapped so firmly around Aradune's longsword as they have been for the past two hundred pages.
 

tad10

Elisha Dushku
5,534
601
There's no way a 5-10 Million dollar game requiring ongoing development, operations, facilities and customer service costs is getting post-KS funding for a projected 20-50K subs @ $60/copy and $15/month. Especially when that successful KS pre-sold 7K copies.

They don't have a business plan. Just a bunch of ideas and hot air.
You are probably right but I like to think that if the KS gets funded (or if not funded gets above 500k) but nothing happens beyond a pre-alpha that explodes, the fact that the KS got funded will inspire another more organized group to try this again but with organization and actual prep.

I could be wrong, but that's why I'm still pledged and supporting this thing despite my misgivings.
 

Aeiouy_sl

shitlord
217
0
Fair enough. I still think Brad is a moron, charlatan, and hack though, and someone who doesn't deserve to have his project funded based on the drivel of shit he's put out since this entire thing started.
So your illogical conspiracy is based on your extreme hatred and dislike for Brad. I can tell you this there is no chance you dislike brad more than I used to dislike him, no way no how.

All you have seemingly done is come here half cocked and just taken a bunch of cheap shots. Pretty clear you really didn't catch up on the proceedings. At least I had the courtesy to read this entire thread before it started posting.

But keep on believing and get a tin foil hat.
 

AmberT._sl

shitlord
29
0
Let me apologize, because you actually impress me. I'm simply amazed you can type with both hands wrapped so firmly around Aradune's longsword as they have been for the past two hundred pages.
It's not half as impressive as you being able to type with your head up your ass. Give yourself some credit.
 

Aeiouy_sl

shitlord
217
0
This thread is getting beyond ridiculous lol.. Why is it every time things start looking up, it's dragged back down with speculation and hypotheticals? Stay on topic people! Lol.. Anyway predictions on combat doc?
Right, we all speculated. That's all we could do. You realized it was speculation and you aren't trying to yell from the rooftops "Have faith! They have a plan!" like some people are. None of us really know. It ended up being a subclass system but nobody knows whether they came up with that during the Crusader write up, or if it was planned from the beginning. Pretending it was "obvious" is ridiculous. Nothing has been obvious except their lack of preparation.
Well since the cleric class had sub classes in it and was the first class launched it is pretty easy to see they did not invite the idea for crusaders.
 

jooka

marco esquandolas
<Bronze Donator>
15,400
6,670
You're no fun buddy, that's too bad
frown.png
I'm not your buddy, we may want the same group oriented MMO to be made that I am supporting, but that has nothing to do with you. You are a fucking looney toon in this world, never to be taken seriously. Same as UT.
 

Khane

Got something right about marriage
20,890
14,718
Why? Because Ben said they had already shared all the assets they had? This has nothing to do with them having fleshed out general classes and sub classes

Some of you have miraculously low threshold for comprehension. I realize some people think being close minded and hateful somehow makes one look like they are just challenging and being hard nosed.
Dummies like beercube or whatever said they did not even think about multi paths until they put the crusader up, which is provably wrong.

It is absolutely false that they decided to create multiple paths for classes only when they came up with the crusader.

It would probably serve everyone well to focus your complaining on real things and not on unfounded and essentially irrelevant conspiracies.
Just stop man. Seriously stop. You're questioning our comprehension? Nobody knows if they had it decided that they were going to subclass or if that was a reactionary move. The only people who know that are Brad and his team. You're sitting here pretending you somehow have more knowledge of Brad's garage than the rest of us. You are speculating. Stop trying to pretend you know what you can't actually know. Really... stop.

At this point it is a much further stretch to say they had that all figured out prior to the KS than it is to say they made it up as they went based on how this project has been handled since the KS was put up. Your blind faith is dizzying.

And you know what? It doesn't fucking matter. The concepts for this game are not even close to being finalized and that's fine because we all know that and they are being honest about it. Who gives a shit if that one small piece was already decided upon or if they decided to do it based on community feedback.