I've literally never thought about my popularity, so you're treading in new ground here and are the expert.So rewarding Tuco coming to the realization that he is a terrible poster and only was ever "popular" because he bullied other moderators once the original FoH was abandoned and rerolled was established.
I'd say my popularity on this forum peaked when I ran a set of return to EQ events in old world zones that happened before emulators were popular. I don't even know when it was, maybe 2007?