I had played SoD for 5 years off and on and still follow up on it without playing for the past 1-2 years just to see how things have changed. Overall, I loved how they customized EQ into it's own lore/game with tomes and stances. The raid game was fantastic utilizing once nostalgic zones creating a new feel of a rpg, but from what I've read Woldaff has been butchering any aspect of what was once a good community for a raiding game. It's been abruptly dumbed down. Massive item nerfs that had been in the game for at least a year just to appease the vision of the current admin and without any notice to the players in most instances. Apparently Woldaff is afraid of higher tiered players making lower tier/older content obsolete. I wish I could find the quote on the forums, but it's pretty much his new outlook on the server. Zaela had a lot of fanastic ideas and really bended what that client version of EQ could possibly do, but once someone disagreed with him/her, they scrapped the idea altogether. Was frustrating to see what could have been.
Woldaff became the torch carrier once Wiz stepped away to work full time on Dawntide. I believe he covers finances if donations don't completely cover the bill for that month, which is really cool of him if that is indeed the case.
But, he has proven himself incompetent when it comes to the dev side of things. He made one halfway decent zone - Plane of Valor - which took a fuckload of work after the fact to iron out bugs; the rest of "his" content has been a fucking joke. His "vision" for the game is everchanging, and there's been two instances where he disappeared entirely for long periods of time, and upon returning immediately decided to nerf a fuckload of items and spells. Item nerfs are still occurring to this day I believe, although I don't quite check the SoD forums as regularly these days. From the way it appeared though when I was playing, he would decide to nerf items/spells/content while only telling MAYBE Slaariel that it was going to happen; I mean fuck the other devs who volunteered to make amazing content.
So yeah, SoD lost Marza aka Thizik, Eisley, Thinkmeats, and Zaela as devs in recent history. All four created amazing content, pushing what the Everquest engine could do to the max. Marza created some of the very best high end content any MMO has ever seen. I'm not sure on Thinkmeats, as I believe he just moved on without any bullshit happening (although I wasn't playing at the time, so not 100% on no BS leading to him quitting). Marza, however, was not creating content nor itemizing the content he created in a way that fit within the bullshit "vision" Woldaff apparently has for Dalaya. Except, you know, it's hard to impose your vision when you disappear for long periods of time. Honestly if Woldaff had any sense, he would have turned over the "vision" for high end content to Marza, giving him some rough guidelines lore-wise to follow. We would have gotten to witness quite possibly the very best high end content EQ, or any MMO really, could possibly offer.
Eisley was such a weird case. He wasn't a dev for long, but he quickly was churning out some very interesting content, both raid and six man stuff. And then he randomly got banned for complete bullshit reasons. Of course it was later revealed to be complete and total horse shit, and he was unbanned; but he was either not welcomed back onto the dev team, or made the decision not to go back to deving - which you can't really blame him for after the way he was treated.
So yeah, TLDR. My apologies for ranting, but shit man. SoD was once on the road to being one of the greatest emulated servers in the history of gaming, but now...well, shitty management will bring down the greatest of empires.