I'm not sure the naysayers get exactly what this game is. This isn't your typical Mmorpg that had an internal beta, beta, and release.
This is a crowd funded mmo. It doesn't necessarily "release" ever. It's an ongoing development. They just basically said they won't wipe the server anymore. That doesn't mean they released the game.
They have been more open and honest about the development of this mmo than any mmo in history. They tell their development schedule ahead of time, tell what didn't make each release, what got changed, etc. The patch notes are more like board meetings than a simple patch note.
All that being said, it's not the game to beat all games. It has a niche market for sure.
If you like the idea of building a characters abilities by actually doing what you want to skill up, then this is probably a good game for you to check out.
If you prefer games where you choose a class and gain abilities for that class by leveling, this probably is not the game for you.