Smartphones

  • Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!



    Go here and give us your nominations!
    Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!

Siliconemelons

Naxxramas 1.0 Raider
12,463
18,905
Nope didnt read, but then did read :) yeah its just a cheaper version of the standard current data plan- sans hotspot ability...but who pays for that? just use freetether or whatever.
 

BrutulTM

Good, bad, I'm the guy with the gun.
<Silver Donator>
14,913
-1,279
Bros, it's time to let those grandfathered unlimited data plans go. Unlimited data is nice, but when most people are around wifi most of the time and have good broadband connections at home, how much is that unlimited data plan really worth? I know people who are buying phones at full price so they don't lose their grandfathered plans. Is that really worth hundreds of dollars to you? Just download shit on wifi. They are going to take it away from you sooner or later anyway, as soon as they think that there are few enough people left on it to minimize the backlash. Just let go.
 

Crone

Bronze Baronet of the Realm
9,714
3,211
Most people on unlimited don't even use anywhere close to the caps that are in place already anyway, so switching would not even effect them.

I let go a few months ago and it didn't make any difference because I figured out the whole family plan had never used more than 1.75gb in a single month anyway.
 

Siliconemelons

Naxxramas 1.0 Raider
12,463
18,905
I peak slightly over 2gb constantly and I hate swapping to WiFi etc- my wife even gets near 2gb per month. So getting 15 to 30 more a month every now and then as overage it is annoying. I always buy my phones used off ebay etc- she is the one that always wants something new... stupid iphones.
 

Crone

Bronze Baronet of the Realm
9,714
3,211
I peak slightly over 2gb constantlyand I hate swapping to WiFietc- my wife even gets near 2gb per month. So getting 15 to 30 more a month every now and then as overage it is annoying. I always buy my phones used off ebay etc- she is the one that always wants something new... stupid iphones.
wtf? Why aren't you leaving it on, so the instant you get in range of a network you've already connected to it connects automatically?
 

Mageling

Bronze Knight of the Realm
232
0
wtf? Why aren't you leaving it on, so the instant you get in range of a network you've already connected to it connects automatically?
I don't because I get 35-40MB download, which around 10x faster than the shitty DSL that's available at my house. Fiber is "on the way," but there's no telling how long it may actually take.

With streaming high quality Google Music, my commute eats up about 100-125mb each direction. I could use low quality streaming, but when I have unlimited through TMO, why do I actually care? I generally eat up about 6-8GB/mo depending on if I set my phone up again.
 

Crone

Bronze Baronet of the Realm
9,714
3,211
Granted google music is great for play anywhere but if I was listening to music that regularly, if invest in an iPod so I wouldn't have to stream that much every day.

But as you say, if you have unlimited then who cares.
 

Siliconemelons

Naxxramas 1.0 Raider
12,463
18,905
I looked at my last 6 months usage I have gone over 2gb three times and my wife has once and twice been at 1.8/1.9 GB usage. So that would be about 120 a year - and that is far less than any subsity I would get from changing my plans -yes. But when I need to, I can use my phone as a hotspot- and do on long car trips with a little sony streamer box plugged into the cars DVD system- even though my pre3 is only 3g- verizon 3g pushes out a decent 1-3mbs my home internet is basic shit- 2-6mbs so there is not much reason for me to swap- other than if I do have a cap and have to play around it.
 

Joeboo

Molten Core Raider
8,157
140
Christ, I have a 50 mbps home internet connection and I get impatient with it at times when downloading something big. I can't imagine having less than 5mbps on a home connection, that's like still living in the 90s.
 

BrutulTM

Good, bad, I'm the guy with the gun.
<Silver Donator>
14,913
-1,279
Try 1-3 Mbps with a 17 gig cap on a 30 day rolling window and if you go over it you are throttled to dialup speeds for 2 weeks. Gotta love satellite "broadband".
 

Deathwing

<Bronze Donator>
17,071
8,076
I've been poking around some more and I think I found the explanation to my problems. Let me go a bit in depth since I understand it better.

I've been getting delays on my push notifications, high pings, and kinda crappy data rates. I originally attributed this to the Nexus 5's cell radio and not ST wireless ATT(I received both at the sametime) since I researched this somewhat beforehand and thought I would see something like this reported. I guess most people don't care about these types problem? IDK, I don't use my data connection that much, which is why I tolerate the horrible 3G VZW service where I live. But delayed push notifications is a deal breaker. That's one of the primary benefits of a smartphone, letting you know shit so you don't have to check it.

Apparently, ST Wireless is REALLY aggressive with closing inactive connections. As in, the ones that need to stay open for push notification to work. In case you didn't know, push notification works by having either your cell phone(on cellular data) or you router leave a connection open is that when a pushed message comes around for your cell phone's IP, it will go through right away. No open connection, it sits there until the connection is reestablished. Which, for everything that uses Google's push service, is every 28 minutes. That essentially destroys the functionality of push. People have found workarounds for this by basically reopening the connection every X minutes, but that can't be good for your battery otherwise Google would have set it there to begin with. And your push can still be delayed up to the max of whatever X minutes. AND it doesn't fix Exchange pushes, which obviously use a different service and likely can't be easily fixed since each implementation is done per business(I'm wildly guessing here).

Second problem is that ST Wireless customers are basically second rate users. Now, this I did know, but I didn't expect how it would manifest. I honestly thought it would just mean a shitty data throughput. I can live with that, I already deal with a VZW 3G that's horrid. This is worse. Pings in the hundreds of milliseconds combined with a reduced throughput will reduce said throughput even more and make even simple mobile page loads REALLY slow. 3-4 bars of HSPA+, I would get ~250ms ping and under 1/1 up/down on speedtests. I've even seen it rumored that ST wireless reroutes ALL data to some servers in AZ, which does explain the pings. What, no LTE speedtests? This is the other aspect of second rate customer I didn't expect. I've seen my phone connect to LTE all of 2 times and both times it was fleeting and 0-1 bars. I've seen ATT's map for my area, I had to move the map 45 miles away just to get some gradient and establish I was actually looking at 4G LTE color. Ithaca is covered in LTE. I'm not even sure how this is managed. ST Wireless customers just not allowed to connect to certain towers? How do they manage to restrict the LTE signal in such a way? How aside, situation sucks.

I know a few other people use ST Wireless here, I'm wondering if you've had the same problems on ATT? Waste of $55 but whatever, that was the whole point of trying it out first. I'm looking into AIO Wireless or ATT Go Phone. Both are prepaid, but ATT owns both. I know AIO is capped at 8 down, but that's more than fast enough for me. Anyone here use either of those services. Can you report if you've had any of the aforementioned problems? How does the service compare to postpaid ATT?
 

Denamian

Night Janitor
<Nazi Janitors>
7,578
20,989
I've been on ST (AT&T) since February and I've never had an issue with push notifications being delayed. Granted, when I'm away from wifi I'm often streaming music or have Ingress running, so it's possible that has been enough to keep my connection open.

As far as data speeds, I've found it to be decent. I'm in Saratoga on HSPA+ and just did a speed test (THe FCC's speed test app is actually pretty good) and I got 6.88 Mbps down, 782 Kbps up with a 143 ms ping. I've got a Nexus 4 and there is no LTE in the area, so I can't test that. One thing about ST is that you'll only be able to connect to towers that AT&T owns and not ones AT&T has agreements with. AT&T's coverage map may show that there is LTE in your area because AT&T's regular customers can connect, but MVNOs are out of luck if the LTE isn't from AT&T towers.

One thing that I have found that helps on data is figuring out which APN works best in your area. The settings that came with my sim card worked ok, but one of the APN settings that came with my current rom (OMNI) seem to get me faster speeds and overall better connections.
 

Deathwing

<Bronze Donator>
17,071
8,076
If you're streaming frequently, yes, that will keep the google port open. Won't help exchange though, do you use that?

I don't think anyone else has much of a LTE network in Ithaca. I know TMO's network is shit around here, it certainly wouldn't account for the gaps I'm experiencing. Who else would have LTE towers up that ATT could roam onto? Your ping could be better, but I'd love if I could even get a stable HSPA+ connection at that speed. HSPA+ is rare and LTE is even rarer.

Any idea where I could go that has a compendium of APNs? From what I've seen so far, this is akin to voodoo. Might as well get my palm read to see if that will improve my speeds.


BTW, looks like pretty much all of saratoga is covered in LTE.
 

Denamian

Night Janitor
<Nazi Janitors>
7,578
20,989
I don't use exchange at all, so I can't test that. I do get push notifications from Gmail and Hangouts promptly when I'm away from wifi.

As far as APNs go, I'll list the 2 main ones that work for AT&T ST:

APN: att.mvno
Proxy: not set
Port: 80
MMSC:http://mmsc.cingular.com
MMS proxy: 66.209.11.33
MMS port: 80
MCC: 310
MNC: 410
APN type: default,supl,mms
APN protocol: IPv4
APN roaming protocol: IPv4


APN: tfdata
Proxy: not set
Port: 80
MMSC:http://mms-tf.net
MMS proxy: mms3.tracfone.com
MMS port: 80
MCC: 310
MNC: 410
APN type: default,supl,mms
APN protocol: IPv4
APN roaming protocol: IPv4

I've been using the first one for several months with no issues. If you do some googling there is a thread on XDA about APNs for ST on AT&T.
 

Deathwing

<Bronze Donator>
17,071
8,076
Edited after you responded. You should check the map again. All of Saratoga has LTE.

Yeah, I've seen that thread on XDA, tried most of them. Some of the just don't work at all. There seems to be a difference between their HSPA+ SIMs and LTE SIMs in regards to what APNs you can use and how well you can work. Might even be affecting the push delay. I'd be willing to use HSPA+ only if it meant I could get those speeds and no delay.

I'm guessing you tested the delay for me? Can you do it a half hour after disconnecting from wifi with no streaming or anything? Default refresher for google services is 28 minutes.