I don't think it's fair to blame Elidroth and the devs for the current pitiful state of EverQuest. I believe he's one of the good guys.
John Smedley is where the blame should be squarely directed. It was he that mismanaged and bungled a potentially great IP and MMORPG franchise. It was Smedley that chased after every silly video game trend. He hired the managers that hired the devs that slowly destroyed EQ. He hired Dave Georgeson and Jeff Butler to run EQ Next which was a disaster of epic proportions that to this day is odious and appalling blemish on the MMO industry that will never be erased.
Over the years, SOE has some of the most inept and incompetent designers to walk the earth working on EverQuest and imbeciles like Absor are still working there if you can believe it. These people are untalented con artists who somehow managed to keep their jobs year after year. Every company has worthless people that are there not because of merit or talent but because they know play the office politics game. SOE is a prime example of the Peter Principle at work where people are promoted to the level of their incompetence. You can start off as a janitor at SOE and someday you may end up being the Creative Director.
Blizzard created a studio culture of excellence and a AAA+ quality MMORPG that should have inspired Smedley and SOE to do better and to fully realize the potential of the EverQuest IP. The roadmap was there right in front of them. But, instead they knew better and EQ and EQ2 faded into relative obscurity. It was Smedley's arrogance and stupidity that was their downfall. But Smedley was too busy with politically correct side projects like trying to get more females in the industry to care. The problem is he is still a player with Amazon. People won't publicly trash him because the MMO dev world is very small and someday they may have to go hat in hand back to him looking for a job.
A fish rots from the head down. Smedley was the head of SOE. The buck stops with him. Sony the parent company of SOE should have fired him years ago. But this is the Japanese way. The Japanese rarely fire people. Incompetence is rewarded.
EverQuest holds a special place in the hearts of hundreds of thousands of dedicated fans. Their love for the franchise was never properly reciprocated by Smedley and SOE. It just breaks my heart to see how the franchise has been so utterly mismanaged and disrespected over the years. The current EQ devs are a disgrace. It's quite obvious that they really don't care about their MMO and even more obvious they don't even play it. Nothing would make me happier than to see Intrepid Studios and Steve Shariff purchase the EQ IP and give it the respect it deserves in a new incarnation.