Final Fantasy XIII-2 is one one of the best RPGs I've played in a long time. It's a huuuuge step up from FFXIII and I highly recommend anyone who skipped it this year after being turned off by FFXIII to go and give it a shot, it's definitely worth playing and a solid game.
yeah, this is what I have heard as well.
Have not tried either though.
I also think 12 was pretty decent really too. (granted never finished it..)
As I said, I really feel credentials needs to come into play, due to rose colored as noted. I've notice the vast majority of 7 defenders, it was their first rpg.
For me, it wasn't. Not even close. I'm 35 now. I did not play ultima's on PC at the time admittedly. Dragon warrior was my first prototypical jrpg. (aka a few text adventures, and roguelikes on the PC prior. but I don't think they count for this discussion directly) so won't include wizardy, shadowgates, etc. But pretty much you name it, played it.
So, personally, I had played Dragonwarrior 1-4. FF 1, 4,6, and emulated 5 and 3, startropics, crysalis, phantasy star 1-3, shining in the darkness 1-3, NES versions of Ultima, exodus, avatar,etc.
Huge rpg fan. I played shit you probably never heard of. ghost lion, faria, etc. Snes lufia series, secret of manas, chronotrigger of course, mario rpg, earthbound , illusion of gaias series, breath of fire series, evo, y's, uncharted, 7th saga, romancing sages, etc.
Seriously, it would be harder to find an RPG thats been released or fan translated to english that I have not played.
Also, now I want to go play some of those again...
Wonder if crysalis is on the nintendo store..