The Hobbit
- Thread starter Feien
- Start date
-
Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!
Go here and give us your nominations!Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!
Cinge
Ahn'Qiraj Raider
- 7,277
- 2,302
It's just one of those things you overlook. Like when that little dorf was rolling in his barrel taking out all the orcs, then he landed did his "Barrel whirlwind", busted out of his barrel and jumped into the river where there was conventaly a spare empty barrel for him to jump back into(all the while bilbo is stuck hanging on the side of one
).
Ravishing
Uninspiring Title
- 8,456
- 3,577
Asmadai
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- 3,196
- 9,204
Aside from being Dwarf-made, specifically from the Dwarves in Erebor, that was about it. It was special in the sense that Bard always managed to retrieve it every time it was shot.
spronk
FPS noob
- 23,352
- 27,210
haha when I first saw the gold dwarf I thought he was going to turn into a dwarf transformer and fight smaug, godzilla style
decent enough movie, I liked kate in lost so she was great here too. I can't believe she spent a year filming her scenes though, must be more in part 3. I don't get the sauron thing at all either, I guess gandalf must get his memory c3p0'd for him to not start preparing now
I know in the book bilbo's ring does work against smaug but it woulda been interesting if dragon magic was stronger than sauron magic and he could see the ring bearer. Would have made a nice suggestion that smaug is older and stronger than sauron, and neither side want him alive. probably piss off fanboi's too much though. the ring worked well against the spiders, against smaug it seemed pretty useless, just being tiny was the bigger help. thorin balancing on smaug's nose was awesome/hilarious.
decent enough movie, I liked kate in lost so she was great here too. I can't believe she spent a year filming her scenes though, must be more in part 3. I don't get the sauron thing at all either, I guess gandalf must get his memory c3p0'd for him to not start preparing now
I know in the book bilbo's ring does work against smaug but it woulda been interesting if dragon magic was stronger than sauron magic and he could see the ring bearer. Would have made a nice suggestion that smaug is older and stronger than sauron, and neither side want him alive. probably piss off fanboi's too much though. the ring worked well against the spiders, against smaug it seemed pretty useless, just being tiny was the bigger help. thorin balancing on smaug's nose was awesome/hilarious.
Brahma
Obi-Bro Kenobi-X
- 12,511
- 45,572
McCheese
SW: Sean, CW: Crone, GW: Wizardhawk
- 6,918
- 4,315
One thing I wondered about (and actually I wondered about this in the book as well) is how did Smaug get all that gold into one giant room? Obviously the dwarfs didn't have their entire national wealth piled in their great hall, and Smaug is clearly too large to enter the smaller chambers and hallways that criss-cross the mountain.
Saw it last night and I liked it a lot. Just generally a much better movie then the first, and they absolutely nailed Smaug. I also didn't mind the she-elf being added. Sure she was there for a forced (but thankfully brief) romance, but most of the fighting action revolved around her and Jedilas so that was okay.
edit: Maybe he hired some folks to move everything and then ate them when they were done McCheese.
edit: Maybe he hired some folks to move everything and then ate them when they were done McCheese.
Ravishing
Uninspiring Title
- 8,456
- 3,577
I thought they showed the Dwarf King in Movie #1 surrounded by all that gold in the hall, except it was more organized. Basically yes, they kept all their wealth there and Smaug basically knocked over all the piles of treasure to create a big pool of gold.
Movie was great, sucks I have to wait another year because they stopped it right before my favorite section of the cartoon version
He did, he went crazy and made a huge scrooge Mcduck moneybin right before Smaug attacked.
Also in the extended version they show why the Elf king hates the dwarfs so much.
Speaking of the movie versus the cartoon.
I really loved some sections of the cartoon dialogue better. For instance, one of my favorite parts is when Bilbo confidently mocks Smaug by telling him he has a scale missing, and Smaug becomes irate at that point
In the movie version that same scene plays a little bit like a comedy.
I also always liked that the black arrow was shot by a magic bow versus the harpoon they have in the movie.
Sure that is closer to the book version, but meh.
I really loved some sections of the cartoon dialogue better. For instance, one of my favorite parts is when Bilbo confidently mocks Smaug by telling him he has a scale missing, and Smaug becomes irate at that point
In the movie version that same scene plays a little bit like a comedy.
I also always liked that the black arrow was shot by a magic bow versus the harpoon they have in the movie.
Sure that is closer to the book version, but meh.
Jysin
Ahn'Qiraj Raider
- 6,457
- 4,345
You would think that would be a crucial bit of information you wouldnt leave out of a theatrical cut. I would happily omit the bullshit singing while cleaning plates scene to fit that in.
McCheese
SW: Sean, CW: Crone, GW: Wizardhawk
- 6,918
- 4,315
That makes sense. I don't remember that scene, but I haven't seen the first one since last December so my memory of it is foggy.