So I've had some time with the Fishman Fluence Keith Merrow set (basically classics, from what I've heard).
I've never been HUGE on actives, however I do enjoy them for some stuff. But.. they were always just EMG, 81 variants. Some people pull that off, but I found the tone very sterile. However, the Fishman's are a beast totally different.
The guitar has a 3-way switch for pickup selection, the standard bridge - neck - combined. The real difference with these is the new "voice" options. Basically each pickup has 3 different voicings. Voice 1 - a PAF clone. Kind of fat and thick, very meaty. Voice 2 - a single coil option. Very punchy, very tight, little twangy. Voice 3 is the "Merrow" option which is just essentially a very hot active pickup sound. This is what I run most of the time, but the other voicings are still good. There's a lot of combos here - 3 voicings each x 3 pickup selections. I'm putting numbers here to the voicings, but it's arbitrary on my party.
No tone knob on this bad larry and honestly, I've never used a tone knob in my life.
The third voicing is pretty raunchy and tight, it definitely has a distinct hot-rodded metal tone. Definitely sounds like Keith. My pickup of choice for passives is the SD Nazgul bridge and Sentient neck which I think Keith Merrow helped design. It's kind of weird because his music isn't necessarily always my style, but the guy sounds goddamn good. I do love these pickups.
I could never justify dropping $300-400 on a set of pickups, and installing all the harnesses and battery compartment if it didn't come with the guitar. For that reason, I'd never buy a Fishman set and probably would buy SD Nazgul/Sentient in the future. But I'm glad I have these - definitely my favorite active pickup and it might be my favorite pickups of all time. Time will tell.
Few other notes. This is a MIK Schecter. I prefer MIJ Ibanez, but this guitar plays VERY well. It definitely plays better than a lot of Ibanez that I have played. And because it's neck-through it is very resonant with a lot of sustain. The guitar is easy to play, and I have a lot of fun playing it. I loved my universe but it did not play as easily as this does (plus changing pickups on a pickguard seriously sucks). I'm very impressed by the build quality and features. I may even be looking for a MK-II version of this guitar in the future.