I dunno, maybe I'm a bit biased, but speaking as someone who was circumcised (as a baby, and I'm not Jewish) and has also heard a of of nasty stuff about circumcision, I don't really have much to complain about. I have never had to had to deal with smegma ("cock-cheese" for the layman) or any of the potential difficulties that arrive from inadequate peen-cleansing, and although I've heard that sex is apparently not as pleasurable for the circumcised, my orgasms have never been anything less than stellar. Plus, my cock always looks ready for a photo shoot.
I don't know if I would have any future sons circumcised, but it's certainly never bothered me at all. For what it's worth.