He would do just the same as Ponder, as I said, the talent gap isn't big enough and a slightly different QB isn't going to make shitty receivers any better when they drop balls delivered strait into their chests 30% of the time. The only reliable guy we have right now is Rudolph like I said in my previous post and Harvin is injury prone and we never know when the time will come when he's out.
The fact you think Smith is what makes this team a contender seemingly is what takes this conversation full retard. The dude has been the brunt of jokes on these forums for the last 2 or 3 years for a reason.