2024-2025 NFL Season - Dak Prescott's MVP Tour Part 2

Nothar said:

Shrug. Herbert has a worse playoff record than both Lawrence and Jones. I do not put any stock into regular season stats when you cannot perform in the playoffs. Herbert undoubtedly has a ton of talent. But he is just not a winner in my opinion. He reminds me of Carson Palmer, who would have great regular seasons but could never win a playoff game.

Click to expand...

Jones was benched and released mid-season, he doesn't even belong in this conversation.

Lawrence...well his one win was the result of some of the most Chargerest Chargering that has ever Chargered. Lawrence threw FOUR picks that game and Herbert put up a respectable performance, the Chargers choked the game away with terrible playcalling, a missed 40 yard field goal, and an incredibly fucking stupid unsportsmanlike from Bosa. Genuinely not Herbert's fault. His game against the Texans on Saturday, yeah that was fucking terrible. A lot of it was due to the awful Chargers Oline and Harbaugh certainly didn't help with his coaching but Herbert put up a career worst day by a mile and there's no excuse for it.

I'm not saying you could stick him on the Chiefs and he'd be balling out at a Mahomes level but I guarantee if you put Mahomes on the Chargers his postseason record would be a bunch of misses and first round losses.