2 black mirror episodes and 3 unrelated generic horror series scripts
This pretty much, though i would call them 3 generic twilight zone scripts. and the 2 black mirror episodes had their own issues.
1 - decent twist but goes on too long and suffers from trying to happy ending it. Average Black Mirror style episode.
2 - is just a murder mystery, not really a twist and the "reveal" doesn't really say anything. Bad Twilight zone episode.
3 - is decent, but way too long and yeah you know exactly what's going to happen its not even really a twist ending. Average black mirror style episode.
4- If this had involved technology, this would of been the best and most "black mirror" ish episode. its filled with social commentary and is though provoking, but the gimmick and twist has nothing to do with technology, this is a good Twilight zone episode.
5 - Again not tech, no real social commentary (though it deals with social issues ie immigration, neither the plot nor the "twist" are related to it). not even really a plot twist here. not sure why people think this one was the best episode.
If I had to rank them it would be 4 > 1 > 5 > 3 > 2 but its not like theres a huge gap between the quality of the episodes. most were just average.
What I really need now is someone to highlight all of the episodes to avoid starting with season 4. I stopped watching after Season 3 and thought that most of the ranged from OK to great but nothing that I would just not watch ever again.
Season 4 was solid tbh. Not all of the episodes were winners but i wouldn't call any of them trash.
1 - USS Callister - nerd power fantasy goes wrong. very black mirrorish, but does do the sappy happy ending thing.
2 - Arkangel - the lengths an over protective mom will go and what it costs her.
3 - Crocodile - insurance investigation reveals a secret...
4 - Hang the DJ - good social commentary about technology and how it impacts us,. Its basically future tinder. this one is like San Junipero episode, where its very black mirror-ish but it naturally has a happy ending (not forced on like some of the other sappy endings)
5 - Metalhead - Boston Dynamics meets terminator. its a black and white artistic future hellscape but not really black mirror ish.
6 - Black Museum - pretty much the same as the White Christmas anthology episode from season 2.
Season 5 is mostly miss. feel free to skip all 3 episodes.