First thing Toney was really good when he fought him, and he embarrassed him. Because he made every pro look like a can, you think he wasn't good?No doubt that Jones was flashier and faster than Mayweather, but technically? Mayweather wins hands down over Jones Jr., technically. Roy was able to dominate fighters so easily because he was just so much fucking faster. The truly great technical fighters are still able to maintain their dominance once they age and their speed slows down. Once his age started to surpass his speed, you saw what happened.
Furthermore, Jones never really beat anybody impressive, outside of maybe Toney, Tarver (who whopped his ass twice later) Hopkins (he was like fucking 20 pounds heavier than Hopkins at weigh-in, so that one is questionable) and maybe Griffin?. The only other really notable victories were against an old Felix Trinadad and a 45 year old (lol) Hopkins. That was always my biggest issue with Jones. The dude fought almost noting but cans in his prime, because he never challenged himself once he got his big HBO contract. He was certainly one of the greatest of his generation and one of the most exciting/tantalizing physical talents the sport has seen, but his resume just isn't good enough to even hold a candle to guys like Robinson, Louis, Ali, Pep, Leonard, etc.
Are you fucking dumb. So let me get this straight the only way Roy could have been the greatest fighter of all times was to face another Roy. Guess what, that person never existed . Roy was way better then anyone when he was young. There still hasn't been anyone with that type of raw speed, and power ever. Who the fuck was going to beat him?? Speed, and power, trump defense. If you can break defense, and they aren't even quick enough to defend it, they are done son.
There is almost no boxer who ever lived that was both that fast, and that powerful in their prime. Boxers just have one of those traits, and they can be a god. Not both at the same time.
It's so funny how people categorize all time greats. Right now they are arguing on ESPN that a guy with a 48-0 record over two decades is not an all time great boxer because his fights are boring. wow....