This released this week (Early Access on Monday...official release tomorrow). I'm enjoying it...there are a few bugs and some mistakes, but most of the complaints I've seen are nitpicking. I have heard from people that there are way too many upsets in Dynasty and that the rankings don't make sense. I haven't seen that in mine...there might be a correlation between that issue presenting and the Dynasty being online. My offline Dynasty seems realistic. I did change all the conferences to how I liked them (moved a bunch of teams back to the PAC12 and BIG12, then placed teams to make more sense geographically...I'm also going to be doing a relegation system), so not sure if that helped somehow.
The game is harder than you'll expect. From what I understand, All-American is closer to All-Madden with Heisman being more difficult than All-Madden. I play on AA with some adjusted sliders. Starting at Coastal Carolina...going to get them promoted to the ACC, then I'll probably take a job with Iowa, Ole Miss, or Texas when the opportunity presents itself. Sometimes streaming on Twitch and thinking about throwing the videos up on YouTube if I get some time to edit or can find someone to do it for cheap.
If you like College Football and want to play a next-gen version, this is great. If you expect it to have everything that NCAA 13 or 14 did, you might be a little disappointed.