Gods and Monsters was better than I thought it would be. Could have been really good, they just sorta flubbed parts of it. The idea was sound, the execution was poor. 6/10 seems about right. I don't like how dark they've gotten since Flashpoint. Like maybe they think Flashpoint being dark was why it was so popular? Flashpoint was a really good story, and it being a dark 'what if' universe made it unique. Making everything dark and killing people in every movie just makes it boring. Throne of Atlantis was a bloodbath, Son of Batman was a bloodbath, Gods and Monsters was a bloodbath, I'm assuming Batman vs Robin will end up being a bloodbath (bout to watch it now), and I don't remember if War was the same but I do remember it just plain sucking.
The one plus side to this new grimdark DC is that they might actually have the balls to do The Killing Joke properly, instead of whitewashing it and turning it into a total abomination.