Not to ruin people's fun, but frankly guild drama shit is a relic of a bygone age. Just be in w/e guild you like raiding with, it really doesn't matter. Also if that guild doesn't work out, just leave and join another guild. Everyone on these TLPs has bounced through a half dozen guilds or more, no one cares.
There are perceptions built from early TLP--prior to the AoC era, basically one guild would win most of the early open world targets. This would cause a panic in every other guild as they realized "oh shit, we won't be able to raid or get gear at all." A large % of the good players then bail from the other guilds and the server is basically controlled for years at that point. The consequences were / are catastrophic.
Come Phinigel, all the TLPers are still in the mindset that open world is supremely important. And technically, on a traditional Phinigel clone it kinda is--the loot differential between a pure AoC guild vs one that gets a lot of open world targets is pretty big. There is also a perception at this time that whatever guild wins to start the server, will be untouchable.
Fast forward to 2024, which is 9 years of AoC and special ruleset TLPs and a lot of tropes have been proven false many times:
- The dominant early guild, often does not in fact dominate the server--Coirnav, Mangler, Selo, Aradune, Mischief, Oakywnd--all of these servers had top guilds peter out on varying timelines, and many other guilds found that they were just fine.
- As the TLP playerbase has gotten "seasoned", the importance of gear has slowly been recognized to be way overrated. You can beat Luclin with basically trash gear. You can beat PoP with pretty poor gear as well due to Dragon Glyphs coming on line at 65. After that you're moving into the end of the open world era so every guild that clears content will have close to the same gearing.
- Mischief loot ends up being so ridiculous that in Mischief literally all gearing at its core is a meme. With a MIschief ruleset gear is just something your guys sell for krono, because gearing your actual raid character is no longer a relevant part of the game at all.
By a huge, huge margin the most fun I have had on a TLP in the last decade has been doing small man stuff. You can actually beat virtually all EQ content with a small crew of friends that actually know how to box, and you avoid the plague that is EQ TLP playerbase that you have to share a large guild with.