Pyros
<Silver Donator>
They're both great main tanks, warrior kinda better as off tank due to stronger snap threat, paladin kinda better as main tank on progression content because Hallowed Ground is an OP defensive cooldown, but both can do either fine. Paladin is boring as shit to play though, while WAR is pretty fun, so personally the only tank I play is my WAR, but that depends on people's tastes I guess. WARs used to be kinda garbage compared to paladins but in 2.1 they buffed them a lot to make them more viable and they've been good since.What's the current consensus on WAR vs PLD for tanking?
To be honest the balance is a bit surprising in the sense that every class is good. They don't have many classes and the classes don't have specs so it makes it much easier to balance I'm sure, but you can basically play any class and no raid would tell you they don't need that class unless they already have it(stacking classes works fine, it's just suboptimal loot and utility wise).