earthfell said:
Sorry for the equally long post, but I trust this one is as worth it for everyone.
Earthfell explained very well - thanks and it was insightful. But no, I haven"t yet read Bakhtin. I"ll add only a few things.
If you haven"t read the literature directly, this topic is very difficult to grasp because you literally have to circumvent your own thinking and habits of thought. Only when you realize that the
wayyou think is influenced and patterned by your culture and not "your own mind", then you can start to ascend beyond it, not in a superior sense, but an objectivist one. That"s why most modern psychology doesn"t help an individual
become an individual, only to adjust himself or herself as closely and smoothly as possible to the society in which they live, to essentially become a yes-man for societal norms, to
wantto behave how one
mustbehave in order to do what society demands. That"s the goal of modern psychology, and it"s not a mentally healthy one.
This is easily illustrated and proven by numerous examples.
Let"s say we were all Klingon. I am a fierce warrior, who"s killed hundreds in combat. Dabamf is passive, docile, perhaps loves agriculture; he loves to grow things, not kill them. Now, in our Klingon culture, what kind of statements would our family, friends, our society, say about Dabamf? He obviously isn"t "normal" like a warrior. Is he sick? Does he have some kind of neurosis? What would the goal of a Klingon psychologist be in this instance? To adjust him as smoothly as possible to warrior life? Is that mentally healthy
for the individual? Their culture demands an extremely aggressive barbarism and shuns activity like farming, even if farming is more productive.
Now let"s visit another culture called America. There, they have something called money or capital, and exchange of capital is an essential part of daily life. They use it for everything: securing property and calling it theirs, sending their kids to good schools, going to a football game, every event or experience in this culture called America has underlying it this exchange of something that is abstract, doesn"t exist outside of the minds of the people that exchange it. As such, competition is an intrinsic part of this ritual of exchange, as people compete to maximize the gain of this abstract thing or to spend the least amount of it.
What"s developed as a result of our culture is a habit of thought where you
think of everything in terms of its exchange value, and this permeates every aspect of life, from language to even our discussion here, love and relationships. When you make statements such as, "I have a girlfriend," the verbage is such that it implies ownership. Look at that very article. "Don"t invest too much time or effort". The very word
investimplies some form of capital and is being used regarding a relationship to another human being. Does that make any sense whatsoever?
What does "I have a cold" mean? You own a virus? What about a million-dollar painting? What kind of painting is it? A billionaire passes away? Who?
This is the
pathology of normalcyof American culture, thinking of things, of people, of relationships, in terms of exchange value, in terms of commodities like earthfell said, not as concrete objects or actual human beings, but what can I get, how much profit can I acquire from this exchange. This thinking extends everywhere, to everything, every experience, and the relationships with every person.
And here"s the point:
It"s not objectively mentally healthy.
So you should not read self-help books and not listen to psychologists who prescribe to you a notion of
adjustment. Do not let others, especially women, affect your actions and thoughts. Do what you wanna do, always. And if the outcome isn"t what you want, you"ll know it wasn"t as important as acting as
youwanted to act.
If you"re interested in knowing more (as you should be; it"s your life and your mind here), you can read many of the literature earthfell mentioned, but I would start with H.G. Wells:
The Country of the Blind - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia