GoT - Is Over, Post Your Drogon Sightings
- Thread starter Araxen
- Start date
-
Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!
Go here and give us your nominations!Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!
Royal
Connoisseur of Exotic Pictures
- 15,077
- 10,643
Last night was the best episode in the entire series, maybe one of the best episodes of any series. I watched Ned loose his head not knowing it was going to happen. The Red Wedding was a considerably more brutal scene than that which I knew was coming (had read the books by then). Even knowing how that fight was going to end didn't take the edge off it for me though. It was a punch in the gut that hurt even though I was braced for it. That's good TV folks.
And it was only the best in a series of great moments on the night. Sansa's interrogation, Jaime and Tyrion, Dany and Jorah, Roose and Ramsay, Arya's laughter. Damn what a show.
Another way of looking at Tyrion's beetle story was that is was a forshadowing of his own future, with the Mountain playing the part of brain damaged idiot and Oberyn as a beetle.
Lady Arryn's death pretty much establishes that the Hound picking you to deliver Arya to is a death sentence, hence her laughter.
As for the Jorah vs Barristan as advisors debate, direct experience as a ruler in some capacity doesn't necessarily trump spending decades in close proximity to those who rule (ie. at court). She obviously would have been better served retaining Ser Jorah, for the benefit of having someone who's views were often at odds with Ser Barristan's, going the team of rivals approach that Lincoln used.
And it was only the best in a series of great moments on the night. Sansa's interrogation, Jaime and Tyrion, Dany and Jorah, Roose and Ramsay, Arya's laughter. Damn what a show.
Another way of looking at Tyrion's beetle story was that is was a forshadowing of his own future, with the Mountain playing the part of brain damaged idiot and Oberyn as a beetle.
Lady Arryn's death pretty much establishes that the Hound picking you to deliver Arya to is a death sentence, hence her laughter.
As for the Jorah vs Barristan as advisors debate, direct experience as a ruler in some capacity doesn't necessarily trump spending decades in close proximity to those who rule (ie. at court). She obviously would have been better served retaining Ser Jorah, for the benefit of having someone who's views were often at odds with Ser Barristan's, going the team of rivals approach that Lincoln used.
Burnem Wizfyre
Log Wizard
- 12,314
- 21,386
I knew Oberyn was dead because that prick GRRM would have to have a way to make my favorite character die again to piss me the fuck off yet I still held hope up until Oberyn lost his teeth. How anyone was surprised is shocking to me, in any other show you could have gone into watching last nights episode knowing Oberyn was fine because they couldn't kill off such an awesome character like Tyrion but not with this fucking show, I'd be willing to bet that fat fucker fist pumped the air when he wrote that shit thinking "2 birds with 1 stone!".
opiate82
Bronze Squire
- 3,078
- 5
You know that losing Jorah is bad for Dany simply because Tywin orchestrated his removal from her side and pretty much every strategical move that guy makes is money. Well, up until he either shares a glass or wine with Oberyn and/or underestimates Varys and/or Tyrion.
Can someone clarify a few things? In the book, it's revealed that Selmy and Mormont both worked for members of King's Landing. On the show, who does Daenerys think Selmy is? Also, who sent the pardon and how did Selmy receive it?
Urgoslav
Treasured Member
- 470
- 506
The thought that somewhere, years ago, there was a fist-pumping George RR Martin:
Jait
Molten Core Raider
- 5,035
- 5,317
Not sure if that's really the argument, or at least it isn't for me. Jorah was who she genuinely listened to, and even loved. He was the one that was there from the very beginning when she was getting buttraped as a fish out of water child. He's also exceedingly more practical and blunt than any of the other advisors. And from a story standpoint everything starts going south for her from here on out. Had Jorah been there she likely wouldn't have made many of the decisions that she did. I'm also fairly sure in one of her later chapters she sadly muses on what his advice would have been.
Barristan is a badass and a great advisor. But she loses a LOT with Jorah's absence, I think that's the point that really cant be well argued against.
Tywin or Cersei sent it. It was discussed a few weeks ago in the episode. Selmy's history is backed by Jorah, who knows exactly who he is (same as in the books I think).
Kreugen
Vyemm Raider
- 6,599
- 793
Tywin sent the letter. They were discussing her and how she had Jorah and Selmy as advisers in the small council scene where he sent Mace Tyrell to go fetch his papers.
And Dany knows who he is on the show because Jorah knows him. They skipped the whole part where he pretended to be someone else.
And Dany knows who he is on the show because Jorah knows him. They skipped the whole part where he pretended to be someone else.
Foggy
Ahn'Qiraj Raider
- 6,292
- 4,878
I am worried the overall story is going to start taking a nose dive. We will still get awesome scenes but where is this even headed? I want White Walkers zombifying the country side, Dragons rampaging, and awesome characters doing something other than dying. It feels like all this investment is never going to amount to anything.
Sutekh
Blackwing Lair Raider
- 7,489
- 106
Dany think's Barristan is Strong Belwas' squire (whitebeard) for a long ass time. I don't remember him working with anyone from Kings landing though.
He is dismissed by Joffrey on the show. Does Daenerys know he was a member of the Kingsguard on the show?
iannis
Musty Nester
- 31,351
- 17,656
Yeah, that's how he's introduced by Ser Friendzone. They do make a point of mentioning it.
BoldW
Molten Core Raider
- 2,081
- 25
They're right outside Mereen iirc. WoW has the battle of slaver's bay in it...either during, or aftermath, is when it's assumed they'll meet...though she did save Tyrion's life unknowingly when they reopened the gladiator pits.
Lejina
(╯°□°）╯︵ ┻━┻
- 4,670
- 12,175
She knows exactly who Barristan is in the show.
By the time Tyrion shows up, Meereen is a pretty big clusterfuck.
Jorah is a seasoned warrior with battle command experience, he has Lordship experience and has been a no bullshit and practical adviser to Dany for years. Nobody is irreplaceable, but he was a genuine asset. There's a reason why Tywin took him away from her.
Something that is never mentioned is how he seemingly knows several foreign languages and the culture of everywhere. To top it off, he's like a mini-Varys: Dany always ask him to find out about some random fucking things and he's always right on the ball with all the information within 24hours. Dude has been pretty good at providing intel.
By the time Tyrion shows up, Meereen is a pretty big clusterfuck.
Jorah is a seasoned warrior with battle command experience, he has Lordship experience and has been a no bullshit and practical adviser to Dany for years. Nobody is irreplaceable, but he was a genuine asset. There's a reason why Tywin took him away from her.
Something that is never mentioned is how he seemingly knows several foreign languages and the culture of everywhere. To top it off, he's like a mini-Varys: Dany always ask him to find out about some random fucking things and he's always right on the ball with all the information within 24hours. Dude has been pretty good at providing intel.
Lenas
Trump's Staff
- 7,559
- 2,299
In the book she finds out about both of their deceits at the same time, that Whitebeard is actually Barristan, and that Jorah has been spying. She sends them both on the almost-suicide mission of taking Mereen through the sewers, and when they both come back she banishes Jorah and forgives Barristan. I assume they revealed who he was in the show so quickly because viewers would have recognized him and made the connection way ahead of time, so they just simplified things. Barristan was never a spy like Jorah.