His Dark Materials
- Thread starter Qhue
- Start date
-
Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!
Go here and give us your nominations!Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!
- 3,372
- 14,821
I really liked the first season. This show is especially poignant because it tries to remain faithful to the source material (even to the point of retaining the risky title "His Dark Materials.")
I am looking forward to it; although it was paced poorly season 2, as I recall. It's a lot of material to cover. And, yeah, they do race swaps but nothing intolerable.
I am looking forward to it; although it was paced poorly season 2, as I recall. It's a lot of material to cover. And, yeah, they do race swaps but nothing intolerable.
- 1
Gask
Silver Baron of the Realm
- 13,120
- 51,320
I can't help you with a comparison but women seem to like it in my experience, it's very female character centric after all. It's the usual chosen one, wonder girl story but it's tolerable. Season one was alright but I got tired of it by the end of that.
Last edited:
- 2
I like the Peripheral more - your mileage may vary.
HDM has the usual HBO advantage of gorgeous costume design and sets, great acting - but the story doesn't really live up to it, and didn't keep me as interested.
ShakyJake
<Donor>
- 7,965
- 20,084
Been looking forward to seeing how this turns out, having read the books usually every couple of years its nice to that they are sticking so close to them.
S3 involves the battle of heaven (and countless other worlds, creatures etc) which I have no idea how they are going to do it but going in hopeful.
S3 involves the battle of heaven (and countless other worlds, creatures etc) which I have no idea how they are going to do it but going in hopeful.
all to build up to the biggest sad point in book history that I always forget about when I go to start reading them again
Chris
Potato del Grande
- 19,681
- -10,580
It's really good. Read the book as a teen and this is a good adaptation of it.
It's about an orphan girl in an alternate universe where people's souls manifest as sentient talking animals everyone can see. Except she isn't really an orphan and her parents are doing some shady shit regarding how souls work and what that energy can be used for.
"His Dark Materials" refer to the mcguffins which are The Golden Compass, The Subtle Knife and The Amber Spyglass - one appearing per season. With all three you can commit the ultimate sin/crime...
Harshaw
Throbbing Member
- 26,866
- 142,821
ShakyJake
<Donor>
- 7,965
- 20,084
ShakyJake
<Donor>
- 7,965
- 20,084
Yeah so the premiere had some stuff that really bugged me.
First, faggot angels as mentioned above. They should be asexual. Where's my asexual representashon!?
* Will is slicing into other worlds looking for Lyra, right? So how does he end up running across the bear which exists in Lyra's world?
* Did the black dude even react to Asriel's fucking talking cat? I would think that'd be a big woah WTF moment.
* I don't care how fucking sharp that pig sticker is, that bear could maul him in a half second. And isn't bear armor like their pride and joy? Good job completely destroying his helmet.
Is this how it played out in the books? Because I thought this was rather dumb.
First, faggot angels as mentioned above. They should be asexual. Where's my asexual representashon!?
* Will is slicing into other worlds looking for Lyra, right? So how does he end up running across the bear which exists in Lyra's world?
* Did the black dude even react to Asriel's fucking talking cat? I would think that'd be a big woah WTF moment.
* I don't care how fucking sharp that pig sticker is, that bear could maul him in a half second. And isn't bear armor like their pride and joy? Good job completely destroying his helmet.
Is this how it played out in the books? Because I thought this was rather dumb.
- 1
Asshat wormie
2023 Asshat Award Winner
- 16,820
- 30,968
All correct points. These two episodes were pretty shit and not the same quality as seasons 1 and 2.
I agree, especially the last one - that scene annoyed me on a number of levels, starting with 'you could at least cut a bit off the edge instead of completely destroying it, you little shit' and finishing up with 'if the villagers have no problem letting the other bear out, you could have just fucking told them that to start with'.
I choose to believe the bear's internal monologue is something like 'I swear to god, these fucking kids'.
- 1
From what I remember of the book, the knife will take you where you want to go otherwise you'd get lost all over reality.
As for the angels, only vaguely recall them being all but invisible at the edge of light but 2 who seem to love each other follow Lyra around and try to keep her safe. I don't remember if they ever say whether angels are m/f or androgenous though
Asshat wormie
2023 Asshat Award Winner
- 16,820
- 30,968
Angels being romantically involved is stupid but I guess it can be a thing if authors want. What's annoying is that you know the show made them faggots on purpose. There was a discussion and they concluded that more faggots are needed on TV and they will push faggotry onto the viewers to support The Message.
- 1