MMA Thread
- Thread starter Wintermute
- Start date
-
Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!
Go here and give us your nominations!Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!
jayrebb
Naxxramas 1.0 Raider
- 14,570
- 14,407
There is room to raise the HW limit. Some of the top talent is a little tight on 265, and you got Brock coming back.
I always felt an extra 10 pounds made sense. You don't want morbidly out of shape fighters allowed, but there is a demand for more breathing space. 275 makes a lot more sense.
Ngannou is at 260. What if he wanted to put some size on on his base for wrestling. So besides the Brock example, Ngannou is another.
I always felt an extra 10 pounds made sense. You don't want morbidly out of shape fighters allowed, but there is a demand for more breathing space. 275 makes a lot more sense.
Ngannou is at 260. What if he wanted to put some size on on his base for wrestling. So besides the Brock example, Ngannou is another.
Why not? They'll just lose and self-select out. It's not like some 400 lbs dude is going to beat Stipe.
I don't think the upper HW limit matters at all; it just costs us a freakshow match every so often. If there were enough athletic, skilled 300+ fighters to dominate everyone under 250, then make another division. That's not the case, though.
Lanx
<Prior Amod>
- 65,311
- 147,282
If you want to keep that from happening, eliminate weight cutting. Dude went into the fight with partial renal failure and should never have been allowed in the ring.
- 1
jayrebb
Naxxramas 1.0 Raider
- 14,570
- 14,407
Well because the commission doesn't like it. It's partially why the HW limit exists. To make sure guys come in shape, and can't just wing it.
If HW becomes open weight no limit then it can get ugly very quick. Guys like the black beast will stop giving a fuck, guaranteed.
If HW becomes open weight no limit then it can get ugly very quick. Guys like the black beast will stop giving a fuck, guaranteed.
jayrebb
Naxxramas 1.0 Raider
- 14,570
- 14,407
Roy Nelson is a good example. Solid hands, decent HW banger. Fun fighter. But if that cap wasn't there, he'd have made an ass out of himself.
Ben Rothwell is another. Also cuts to 265 and is already out of shape at 265.
Forcing guys like them to do cardio is a boon.
Ben Rothwell is another. Also cuts to 265 and is already out of shape at 265.
Forcing guys like them to do cardio is a boon.
Weird place to draw the line, IMO. Weight cutting is encouraged and is a much bigger health risk than coming in fat. We don't tell Cormier he can't compete at LHW because he's fat. The 205 limit isn't making him in better shape, it just makes him cut more. If you're worried about out of shape athletes over-exerting themselves, set a body fat % limit or something.
Jozu
Bronze Baronet of the Realm
- 6,984
- 6,295
Holy shit. Hardy is dead in the eyes, shark brain guy, but he has some serious fucking power.
He beat this guy like he owed him money.
And gotta give him credit, he made the switch to MMA, and has actually started to carve out a real career for himself.
He beat this guy like he owed him money.
And gotta give him credit, he made the switch to MMA, and has actually started to carve out a real career for himself.
Lanx
<Prior Amod>
- 65,311
- 147,282
theres no one exciting at mw tho, and lulz who even remembers jan is lhw champ?
- 1
Goatface
Avatar of War Slayer
- 9,889
- 15,678
Jones' problem was Francis' problem, the long ass wait. if Francis wasn't constantly bitching about getting another shot, Jones would be the one fighting Stipe next. so he really only has a few options. If Francis wins, fight him in the summer. If Stipe wins, he will probably fight winner of Blades/Lewis as Stipe wouldn't want to fight till like Oct or something. read somewhere he wants Reem over Blades/Lewis or Rozen. also heard talk he is aiming for 250lb fight weight.
anyway supposedly this just happen lol
- 1
