Izo
Tranny Chaser
- 19,458
- 23,520
If you feel the need to restrict access, then you're already far down the losing road. I thought we went over this mechanism a while back, like spanking your kid - if you see that as the only option, you failed hard.Of course MAC filtering will keep the kid off the net. Keep to internet-doctoring, you're no IT security guru.
I know this may be hard for you to understand, but let us imagine that he did talk to his kid and that his kid tried to get over anyway. Scheduling is actually a fairly common way for parents to enforce screen time restrictions, and programming that into the router takes all of the conflict out of it. To me, it is the second best option.
I understand perfectly what you're saying. It's not really rocket science to set up mac filtering and scheduling on home routers. Did I mention I was CCNA, TSM, MCSE a while back? Oh well, Mr. IT guru. Anyway, to humor you, reset to default, other points of access, assuming you don't live in the amazon jungle - neighbors wlan, borrowing a friends 3g dongle etc etc etc. I'm sure keeping a mac address positive list is serious business for you if you have guests or your wife has friends over or whatnot. That's just silly to me, regardless of how seamless you can set it up.Let me google circumventing mac filter for you.
Assuming they don't get that far circumventing - age or maturity - I'd think your solution last only so long as your kids find out it works differently elsewhere - friends, school, library, whatnot - no scheduling or filtering in the same way. That leaves you with a kid who knows you're a dick who prefers to restrict them rather than talk to them. It seems short sighted, and rather detrimental for future talks of importance. I'd talk to them instead, repeatedly and in due time before the problems arise. And when they do arise, then talk to them some more. Why must it always be about being in control like some roman Pater Familias - punishing, restricting? Didn't they teach you Newtons third law in school?
It's much the same with microorganisms to draw a parallel to a universe I know a fair bit about - you chose the selection pressure with invasive procedures, antibiotics and whatnot. To put it simple, selection pressure drives MRSA and other multi resistant organisms on a short scale. That's what we want to avoid - don't force your kids to be good at circumventing your security measures - unless you really want them to be IT nerds. Give them other challenges in life, academic, whatnot, and in due time to reduce the pressure. Guide, don't restrict. Depending on your schedule, that is what you're doing. But it's not seamless and undetectable in the long run - and you're already down the path that can lead to conflict anyway.
Lastly, I don't think it's a great idea to restrict the social lives of kids. The internet, facebook, twitter, whatnot is their way of communicating and socializing. Pressure them on this vital point and they may react stronger than we like - if it's too restrictive. I'm sure you know what acetaminophen poisoning does for instance. I'm not advocating one let fear dictate parenting strategy, but some things are not worth the hassle.
I'm sure we agree on most. You think the filter is smart, I don't. My question would be: What would a Chaos approved non provocative schedule look like? Why are you not running into problems with this?