I didn't read the whole thread but my take on shit:
Match: Ok but not great. A lot of christian bitches "must love jesus types". I had atheist on my profile so that kept them out. I went on 3 dates from match. One led to sex on the first date, anal, the whole nine yards. It was great. Second, sex on the second date (I'm still boning her), third was a fucking disaster. I'll never date younger again, too fucking stupid.
OKCupid: No luck at all but I wasn't very proactive either.
POF: Fucking pay dirt. I went on I don't know how many dates and smashed them all. All of them had jobs, all of them looked like their pics. When you're 37, you aren't too picky but I am not fucking any fat chicks. Most of them dumb as hell but ok for a date and there isn't much talking going on when I am getting to business.
Adult Friend Finder: Don't waste your time.
Common Thread: I got A LOT of fat chicks sending me winks, "hey" messages and shit like that. Quite a few from the over 40 crowd too. Not that I am against banging an older broad but you better be bringing some heat.
My two cents.