So, someone help me out here because I don't see the appeal of actually playing these types of games. There's only so many dudes I can club with giant dildos before the whackiness wears off and it just becomes a sandbox with bland shooter gameplay.
I gave SR2 a try, got bored, wrote it off as crappy controls on the PC. Tried SR3, pretty much the same. Played it on hard and was just amazed at how sloppy I could be with the shooter mechanics. If I didn't get these games in that dirt cheap humble bundle, I would have been pissed. Every single game, was either shit or wouldn't even run(except company of heroes! Already played those). Red Faction and Metro 2033 probably would have sucked anyway.
Saints Row isn't for everyone. I certainly don't like every game out there, even the ones that are highly reviewed.
But Saints Row had plenty for me to like:
Saints Row 2, receiving a frantic call for help after you've been drugged: "Why is there a leprechaun in my phone?" "Don't worry little leprechaun, I'll save you!"
Saints Row 2, after booting homeless people out of their filthy encampment (paper reads: Homeless Bums now more Homeless): "Correction, this place is a fucking dump, with _potential_!"
Saints Row 3, in a VTOL jet: "It's like a helicopter fucked a plane!"
Saints Row 3 has something like twelve different way to hit someone in the groin. I've done a few thousand of those and keeps getting funnier.
Saints Row 3: "Dick move, unicorn. Dick move."
Saints Row 3: "You should be seeing a visual representation of the Decker Use-Net now." "You know what I see, Kinzie? I'm. A. Fucking. Toilet!"
Saints Row 4 look promising to me. If you didn't like 3, then you probably shouldn't waste your time and money on it.