Shōgun

Cybsled

Naxxramas 1.0 Raider
16,565
13,069
I sort of read it differently. Presuming Toronaga was correct in his observation with Mariko at the end of the episode, Hiromatsu effectively threw himself on a grenade to prevent the rest of the generals from killing themselves in protest. I don't think Toronaga wanted Hiromatsu to die originally, but he also couldn't deviate from his deception of surrender and had to let the thing play out.
 

Tuco

I got Tuco'd!
<Gold Donor>
45,523
73,613
at first i thought the same, but later it seemed to hint that it was a planned suicide to make toronaga look like he had lost all support, even amongst his closest retainers. a feudal japanese lord is not above using vassal suicides as a means to an end.
There's no reason to believe that Toronaga planned that suicide, though. It was merely a convenient way to convince his enemy he was going to surrender. Why was this important? So his brother would let him laze about instead of taking him directly to Ishido? That whole part was pretty contrived.
 

Bald Brah

Bronze Knight of the Realm
317
351
I think it was meant to show how cold and calculating Toronaga really is. This wasn't just a retainer, this was Toronagas best lifelong friend.

The show always paints Toronaga as the sympathetic figure and Ishida as the "bad" guy. But I think at the end it's meant to flip the script. I believe it reveals Toronaga has always been angling behind the scenes for the power of Shogun. He most likely did commit the crimes the council wants him dead over. Ishida really is trying to keep the council of five in power but Toronaga outplays him with these maneuvers. Using Mariko to turn the heir's army to his side ensures the defeat of the council, and right after that the defeat of the emperors forces as well.

Toronaga assumes total control and only allows the emperor to live as a captive. Even though it is not revealed until the last scene I think it was implied that Toronaga was always angling to be the Shogun, and really is the "bad" guy from the Imperial perspective.
 
  • 4Like
Reactions: 3 users