Finally saw it, and shooting from hip on my opinion before rereading what all yall got for it.
Started out jimmy rustled on technical stuff I just couldn't give up. Xwings now have drop down big rotating blaster?ok.... Tie fighters seem standardized to have 2 pilots.... wtf. I get they needed a bro moment for those 2 but to change things up so drastically, they may as well have altered the tie design more to indicate some new model that's somehow better with a rear shooting cannon on a fighter... Just as an old purish hate them suddenly changing something like that up so much. I wasn't thrilled with the super hero movie ending with gigantic earthquake rifts that folk were able to easily walk away from. Old star wars the big ships just take a big hit and you see storms toppling everywhere. Also loved /sarcasm the "Dont ask me why I have the original lightsaber that was dropped at Bespin, a wizard did it" response. Other stuff like blowing up 2 laser turrets is the magical "oh boy we can escape" from a star destroyer? Sorry had way more guns on them than that, so happy they at least got taken down by a missile. Rollerball droid is retarded. Her in the end getting on falcon again with her dumb scrap metal stick when I doubt it would have been kept with her after she was kidnapped... Are they going to play her as the second coming of christ jedi because she goes from no hint of it, to without training mind controlling and whatever else? I especially love the I'm about to lose, but he mentioned the force and training me, so I'm going to spend 15 seconds looking like a tard, while he does nothing to kill or capture me, and by thinking warm fuzzies about the force, suddenly I'm a martial bad ass..... ok.
And darth pussy's voice? Comically bad.
I did love the extra oomph to the weapons, as absurd as it was for the falcon to be doing engine off barrel rolls and such was still entertaining. (Though was like wtf did he get in bottom instead of top gun initially, why was he ever facing "forward" to get the gun locked to.
But what was kinda killing it for me was plot. I don't mind the quirky references to the old movies, it is the "future" after all. The chess table etc. But the amount of like trying too hard to be funny stuff, especially Han using chewies gun was cringe worthy. (Because he never used it before and just started?) But mainly that is was essentially like lets repackage the original movie with the same plot line all over....WTF? They knew huge viewership, was hoping for a more original story.
Instead you have:
Start on desert planet, rough living, poor farmer/salvage kid : Check
Forested rebel base with everyone running around pointlessly. Pathetic "fleet" of a few dozen fighters? Check
Incoming death star to destroy said base: Check
Shields to be taken down so a random exposed component can be destroyed: Check (Love exact mon calamari quote of Our weapons can't get thru shield of that magnitude or whatever...)
Token someone is someone elses father: Check
I tried to be open minded, like I said a whole lot better than prequals. But just so much that doesn't make sense given end of ROTJ. Being one who read all the books up until they started getting retarded when first prequals came. (So Zahns books and others of that era. Think Rogue squadren was last decent ones before the lime green and oddball color bordered books with shitty cover art.