The Astronomy Thread

  • Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!



    Go here and give us your nominations!
    Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!

Burnem Wizfyre

Log Wizard
12,324
21,420
5 rapebux that, in the end, it'll be something boring.
That is almost always the case
frown.png


frown.png
 

spronk

FPS noob
23,359
27,218
its almost certainly a spot where lightning from dust storms hit the ground and melted sand giving it that glassy look. but man it'd be awesome if its the tip of an alien spaceship, crash-landed a billion years ago. that would certainly set off a space race to mars
 

Lambourne

Ahn'Qiraj Raider
2,866
6,838
Astronomer Phil Plait's views:(I removed video links etc since they are already posted here)

[UPDATE: When I wrote the headline for this article, I thought there was evidence the meteor had broken up in a single event while still high up in the atmosphere, so I used the word "explode". I don't want to mislead people; there may not have been any explosion at all. To be clear, the "explosion" heard in so many videos below is almost certianly from the shock wave of the meteoroid, and not from it exploding or hitting the ground.]

Apparently, at about 09:30 local time, a very big meteor burned up over Chelyabinsk, a city in Russia just east of the Ural mountains, and about 1500 kilometers east of Moscow. The fireball was incredibly bright, rivaling the Sun! There was a pretty big sonic boom from the fireball, which set off car alarms and shattered windows. I?m seeing some reports of many people injured (by shattered glass blown out by the shock wave). I?m also seeing reports that some pieces have fallen to the ground, but again as I write this those are unconfirmed.

Note: This is almost certainly unrelated to the asteroid 2012 DA14 that will pass on Friday. See below for details.

[Let me be clear: This is breaking news, and reports are coming in so fast I can?t keep up. I?ll update this post as I can, but treat everything here as tentative until I can get more information! Note also lots of hoaxes are turning up, like a video of a flaming crater that's actually a flaming pit in Turlmenistan that's been burning for decades (called "The Door to Hell"). Be cautious and be skeptical.]

Dozens of videos are popping up on YouTube, and some are incredible. This one from a car?s dashboard camera shows the meteor coming through the atmosphere.

This one is even more amazing: it shows the trail of smoke in the sky, and 27 seconds in the shock wave?the sonic boom?passes over. It?s loud.

My heart was pounding watching those. I have to admit, at first I was thinking this was an elaborate hoax, but the reports are coming in from everywhere. The videos show it at many different angles.

I?m trying to piece together what happened from the videos. First of all, I do not think this is related in any way to the asteroid 2102 DA14! For one thing, this occurred about 16 hours before DA14 passes. At 8 kilometers per second that?s nearly half a million kilometers away from DA14. That puts it on a totally different orbit.

For another, from the lighting, time of day, and videos showing the rising Sun, it looks like this was moving mostly east-to-west. I may be off, but that?s how it looks. DA14 is approaching Earth from the south, so any fragment of that rock would also appear to move south-to-north.

So again, I think this is unrelated to 2012 DA14. But wow, what a huge coincidence!

I don?t know how big the meteoroid (the solid part) of this was. The information is too scattered; we?d need the position of the people who took the videos to triangulate and see how far up the debris trail is, for example. I?ll note that people were taking video of the trail for some time before the explosion is heard, which is consistent with it being the shock wave from the passage of the meteoroid through our atmosphere high above the ground. I know a lot of folks will think that?s the sound from the explosion due to impact, but it?s more likely to be the sonic boom from something big moving at multiple times the speed of sound through the air.

As far as impact goes, the most likely scenario is that this broke up many kilometers above the ground, and may rain down chunks. Many large meteors do this, with meteorites (the pieces that fall to the ground) found downrange. Once the fall is found, we?ll be able to get a better idea of how big this thing was, and of course what it was made of (rock, metal, a mix of both). I?m trying to track down reliable reports of actual impacts.

The train (the term used for a meteor trail) is interesting indeed. It appears to split, so I?m guessing the main mass split there. That?s not surprising; it?s happened with previous falls (like Sikhote-Alin). That means they could have disintegrated at different times, so there may be multiple places where pieces could fall.

For now, that?s all I have. I?ll update this post as I hear more.
 

Lambourne

Ahn'Qiraj Raider
2,866
6,838
I don't believe for a second they shot it down. The only way to hit something going 5-10 miles/second with a missile is from the front, and that would mean you have to accurately know it's trajectory ahead of time, and of course even know it is coming in the first place. Probably just confused people seeing the thing break up (normal) and hearing the sonic boom.
 

Soygen

The Dirty Dozen For the Price of One
<Nazi Janitors>
28,433
44,761
Wow, some of those videos are phenomenal. Crazy shit.
 

Tuco

I got Tuco'd!
<Gold Donor>
47,439
81,031
This event is an incredible once-per-generation thing, I'm glad I live in an age where we can capture this shit on camera. Now I know that if I ever see a meteor explode in the air it's time to gtfo and away from windows.
I don't believe for a second they shot it down. The only way to hit something going 5-10 miles/second with a missile is from the front, and that would mean you have to accurately know it's trajectory ahead of time, and of course even know it is coming in the first place. Probably just confused people seeing the thing break up (normal) and hearing the sonic boom.
I agree, no way was it shot down. The meteor was exploded via natural causes from the atmosphere.

Here's a description that makes the most sense:

http://www.foxnews.com/science/2013/...ral-mountains/
foxnews_sl said:
Donald Yeomans, manager of the U.S. Near Earth Object Program in California, said he thought it was probably "an exploding fireball event."
"If the reports of ground damage can be verified, it might suggest an object whose original size was several meters in extent before entering the atmosphere, fragmenting and exploding due to the unequal pressure on the leading side vs. the trailing side (it pancaked and exploded)," Yeoman said in an email.
"It is far too early to provide estimates of the energy released or provide a reliable estimate of the original size," Yeomans added.
 

Soygen

The Dirty Dozen For the Price of One
<Nazi Janitors>
28,433
44,761
This event is an incredible once-per-generation thing, I'm glad I live in an age where we can capture this shit on camera. Now I know that if I ever see a meteor explode in the air it's time to gtfo and away from windows.


I agree, no way was it shot down. The meteor was exploded via natural causes from the atmosphere.

Here's a description that makes the most sense:

http://www.foxnews.com/science/2013/...ral-mountains/
Araysar just wanted to give his people props for shooting down meteorites. Cut him some slack.
 

Loser Araysar

Chief Russia Reporter. Stock Pals CEO. Head of AI.
<Gold Donor>
80,150
160,365
A Russian SAM shot down a F-117 several years ago. If we can take that out, meteorite is not a problem.

Even back in 1980s, USSR had SAMs with a velocity of 5,000+ MPH
 

Cutlery

Kill All the White People
<Gold Donor>
6,941
20,790
A Russian SAM shot down a F-117 several years ago. If we can take that out, meteorite is not a problem.

Even back in 1980s, USSR had SAMs with a velocity of 5,000+ MPH
So you're saying F-117A > Meteorite?