The gameplay is good, but it's not enough to bring me back. I will say that I found the combat/monster system in 13-2 was far better than 13; and I actually am one of the few that liked 13. I just got to the last area, and the 1-2 hours before getting here where they really went heavy into the story really sealed the game's fate for me. I mean, we didn't care about what happened at the end of 13 at all, then SUDDENLY we remember it all. And when you look at Caius, you really don't see ultimate badguy material. He looks like Steven Tyler in the 80's.
Kefka was a badass. Sephiroth was a badass (mostly). Even the judges in FF12 were more badass. Caius is a letdown.
With all that said... the last boss of 13 was O_O as well. I remember getting to that battle and going "what the fuck is this shit." Did not look as expected to me. Plus I killed it in one try easily. I was a bit overpowered as I grinded some major levels in that little grinding loop you could do, but I thought it would put up more of a fight.
Picture for reference: