Why the Sequels Suck part II
The matrix plot craters regarding why people are used for energy and why the machines keep preserving Zion ect. could have all been neatly summed up if the origins of the machine system were explored further. The only thing we get are a few lines by Morpheus in the first movie.
"A singular consciousness that spawned an entire race of machines. We don't know who struck first - us, or them. But we know it was us that scorched the sky. At the time they were dependent on solar power and it was believed that they would be unable to survive without an energy source as abundant as the sun. Throughout human history, we have been dependent on machines to survive. Fate, it seems, is not without a sense of irony."
And a really silly animation in the Animatrix proposing that the whole war started over a malfunctioning nanny bot. Think Rosie from the Jetsons, on trial for murder.
Anywho... If the sequels had revealed something else entirely about the origin of the conflict. The movies would have been given some real depth. Something like this:
Turns out that humanity did scorch the sky, but not because they were fighting the machines. It was the result of some massive industrial accident in space or something that released a shit load of particulate matter that would stay airborne for the next thousand years.
Vegetation starts dying, animals start starving. People are racing around trying to set up energy and food production methods not dependent on the sun. Eventually a group decides that the only way to survive this is to wait it out. And by wait it out they choose to create a system that will keep a large population in a sort of stasis while automated machines process the atmosphere and clean up the mess. And so they create the Matrix.
But it doesn't quite work out as planned. The machines are made autonomous and have factories that can build more of them, and have machines to fix the factories ect. But the program runs into a snag, the clean up process never really happens the way it's supposed to; And now the machines proceed to "clean up" everything else by eliminating it. The sky is never going to get fixed, and humanity is never going to wake up.
The people who built the matrix had estimates as to how long the clean up process was going to take but didn't know for certain. So they established a program to "unplug" individuals at regular intervals so they can determine if it would be suitable for the matrix to be shut down and for humanity to be revived. This is were the resistance comes from. They are the individuals who are woken up to assess the situation, but the machines immediately try to eliminate them. Somehow over the ages enough people have survived to create Zion. Or more accurately, the survivors find the ancient remnants of the systems that were developed to sustain humanity without solar power and establish Zion there.
And that is where we are when the first matrix movie comes in.
That would explain just about everything and give an even more ironic twist to the whole situation. And just like how Agent smith is worried that once Zion is destroyed the matrix wont need him anymore, the machines might be trying to preserve the current situation so they never "outlive" their purpose.
I want to hire myself out as a script editor. People bring me stories and I tell them why they suck; and what to do to make them awesome.