The Witcher

  • Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!



    Go here and give us your nominations!
    Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!
K

k^M

Blackwing Lair Raider
2,743
2,009
rhinohelix said:
You don't kill the fucking main character of the whole series when you lose an actor. There are 7 books + more stories; why would you kill the star (Geralt) when you have to replace the actor? Don't get me wrong, I love Henry Cavill, he's the only watchable thing on the show but you didn't pay for the rights to The Cavill, no matter how woke you are, the story is Geralt's and his relationship with Ciri and Yennifer and them becoming a family.
Click to expand...
That's why I said continue the story with a different name attached. Take iron man for example, it was dumb as shit swapping a new actor in for Rhodes and then calling him the same, they could have named him John Smith and just used the exact same plot/story arcs.

Might be just a personal irritation of mine, but its always jarring. Bonus points in Harry Potter when they swapped one of Malfoys cronies with a black guy cause the white guy got arrested
 
Cybsled

Cybsled

Naxxramas 1.0 Raider
17,214
13,760
It's a fantasy show, so they could use magic or some shit to change him I guess.
 
  • 1Barf
Reactions: 1 user
Gutterflesh

Gutterflesh

Parody Account
<Gold Donor>
8,548
45,156
Cybsled said:
It's a fantasy show, so they could use magic or some shit to change him I guess.
Click to expand...
1864686A-2CEF-4A8E-B479-C3222BCF9C7F.gif
 
  • 8Worf
Reactions: 7 users
rhinohelix

rhinohelix

Dental Dammer
<Gold Donor>
3,132
5,163
k^M said:
That's why I said continue the story with a different name attached. Take iron man for example, it was dumb as shit swapping a new actor in for Rhodes and then calling him the same, they could have named him John Smith and just used the exact same plot/story arcs.

Might be just a personal irritation of mine, but its always jarring. Bonus points in Harry Potter when they swapped one of Malfoys cronies with a black guy cause the white guy got arrested
Click to expand...
Like when that one guy couldn't be James Bond anymore, so they just changed the name of the spy? Jimmy Bundy? I appreciate your preference and understand what you are going for but that's not the way this IP in particular (or most IPs, really) works. Geralt of Rivia is the star of the books and the games: There are other witchers, sure, but no one wants to hear stories about *them*, really. They don't have 7+ books and 3+ games about them.
 
  • 1Worf
Reactions: 1 user
Z

Zweischneid

Molten Core Raider
838
-852
Don't think re-casting Rhodes or Banner (and most of Thor's posse and presumably soon Gen. Ross) ever slowed the MCU. Batman's been re-cast ... 6-7 times in the last 20 years? They'll be fine.
 
Brahma

Brahma

Obi-Bro Kenobi-X
12,705
47,497
Remember how badly this went with Spartacus? No one accepted his replacement. Not his or the shows fault, but Whitfield was perfect in that role also.
 
  • 2Like
  • 1Solidarity
Reactions: 2 users
stupidmonkey

stupidmonkey

Not Smrt
<Gold Donor>
1,915
4,531
Brahma said:
Remember how badly this went with Spartacus? No one accepted his replacement. Not his or the shows fault, but Whitfield was perfect in that role also.
Click to expand...
We'll Whitfield died so circumstances are a bit different here and the lesser Hemsworth isn't appealing to me as a replacement seeing what he's done before. If season 3 is worse than 2 with Cavill then it won't matter much either way.

I find myself dropping shows quickly now once the plot and quality drop to say a Dexter season 5. Only reason most people are probably gonna stick around for season 3 is because of Cavill.
 
  • 3Like
Reactions: 2 users
Ridas

Ridas

Pay to play forum
2,892
4,144
Spartacus still worked after whitefields death, because the whole thing was glorious.
Witcher was crap from the get go and Cavill and his scenes made it somewhat ok. 2 very different bars of quality.
 
  • 3Like
Reactions: 2 users
Drinsic

Drinsic

privileged excrementlord
5,817
6,260
Cybsled said:
It's a fantasy show, so they could use magic or some shit to change him I guess.
Click to expand...
Can't imagine any way to not make that end up retarded.

"Geralt, you look different."
"Yes, I underwent the Sorceresses' transformation to become smaller, uglier, and generally less likeable."

The only instance I can think of where a lead swap didn't fail miserably is Spartacus and it barely worked that case - and that was fueled by the actor's death. That show was great for a hundred additional reasons in addition to Whitfield, not just because of him. Changing the lead actor in a show that is completely carried by that lead actor is never going to work.
 
  • 3Like
  • 1Worf
Reactions: 3 users
Brahma

Brahma

Obi-Bro Kenobi-X
12,705
47,497
Ridas said:
Spartacus still worked after whitefields death, because the whole thing was glorious.
Witcher was crap from the get go and Cavill and his scenes made it somewhat ok. 2 very different bars of quality.
Click to expand...


The spinoff worked. Hell it was better than the original in every aspect. I personally didn't finish Spartacus the original. Just wasn't good after his death IMO.
 
wormie

Asshat wormie

2023 Asshat Award Winner
<Gold Donor>
16,820
30,968
Switching to Hemsworth is not even about the look and more about personality. There is no way he can step into Cavills shoes. Cavill defined that role, anyone else would look like a poor imitation and will not be accepted. Everything after Season 3 is DOA.
 
  • 1Solidarity
Reactions: 1 user
Cybsled

Cybsled

Naxxramas 1.0 Raider
17,214
13,760
Spartacus: Gods of the Arena was great. S3 and onward was good, but not fantastic. That just shows that other good supporting actors and good story can buoy the loss of a main actor/character if needed

But Spartacus was still a historical drama (even if it played fast and loose with history). They just had to go along and say “this is Spartacus all along”. It’s not ideal, but you don’t have many options

Doctor Who or Star Trek or whatever can use fantastical elements to explain actor changes and make it fit the story. I think they’re going to go this route.
 
Malakriss

Malakriss

Golden Baronet of the Realm
12,741
12,135
The bottom line is they are flat out stating Cavill would be in S4 if the writers / direction weren't the way they are. Tells you all you need to know.
 
  • 6Like
Reactions: 5 users
Ambiturner

Ambiturner

Ssraeszha Raider
16,078
19,628
Malakriss said:
The bottom line is they are flat out stating Cavill would be in S4 if the writers / direction weren't the way they are. Tells you all you need to know.
Click to expand...

Not sure who you're referring to as "they," but nobody official has "flat out" said that. Even though it is the most likely case
 
Hoss

Hoss

Make America's Team Great Again
<Gold Donor>
27,626
16,063
wormie said:
Switching to Hemsworth is not even about the look and more about personality. There is no way he can step into Cavills shoes. Cavill defined that role, anyone else would look like a poor imitation and will not be accepted. Everything after Season 3 is DOA.
Click to expand...

20221107-ctGfY4PA-p3@2x.jpg
 
  • 2Worf
Reactions: 1 users
Hoss

Hoss

Make America's Team Great Again
<Gold Donor>
27,626
16,063
k^M said:
Take iron man for example, it was dumb as shit swapping a new actor in for Rhodes and then calling him the same, they could have named him John Smith and just used the exact same plot/story arcs.
Click to expand...

What? They changed the actor for rhodes?

jayrebb said:
View attachment 442414

Frosk is calling him James Franco now.

View attachment 442415
Click to expand...

Yeah because adult women clearly cannot make decisions for themselves. Just go ahead and out yourself as a misogynist frosk.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user
You must log in or register to reply here.