Mist
REEEEeyore
- 31,199
- 23,382
True Detective
- Thread starter Fedor
- Start date
-
Guest, it's time once again for the massively important and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!
Go here and give us your nominations!Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Give us your worst ones!
Bondurant
Ahn'Qiraj Raider
- 3,845
- 4,792
A lot ofnegative opinionsare about how s2 is bad compared to s1. S2 didn't have Fukunaga working hard with Pizzolatto, and both Harrelson & McConaughey being executive producers.
S2 is Pizzolatto doing his stuff alone, asking Justin Lin (Fast and Furious director) and some other yesman directors to film his shit with as we've seen no actual rewriting (some dialogues really feel like written during some writing intern poop pause).
It's obvious writing /script didn't really go through a lot of people this time. Let's just hope for s3 they hire a competent showrunner to check Pizzolatto stuff in line and creative directors who don't stick to 101 US cop show book.
S2 is Pizzolatto doing his stuff alone, asking Justin Lin (Fast and Furious director) and some other yesman directors to film his shit with as we've seen no actual rewriting (some dialogues really feel like written during some writing intern poop pause).
It's obvious writing /script didn't really go through a lot of people this time. Let's just hope for s3 they hire a competent showrunner to check Pizzolatto stuff in line and creative directors who don't stick to 101 US cop show book.
Szlia
Member
- 6,629
- 1,375
Harrelson and McConaughey were still executive producers for season 2 and so was Fukunaga. On top of that, the absolutely competent Justin Lin (who wrote and directed a couple well rated indies before being asked to helm the surprisingly decent Tokyo Drift - and who would blame him to have stayed for the over the top blockbuster sequels?) directed just two episodes of the season (the first two, so you could say he set the tone, but still...).
What is it you guys don't understand about the fact that he was in the middle of nowhere and could have likely died without a car ride out.
Sterling
El Presidente
- 13,092
- 8,067
Sterling
El Presidente
- 13,092
- 8,067
Bondurant
Ahn'Qiraj Raider
- 3,845
- 4,792
There are different levels of executive production. Good luck saying your piece when you're not even on the filming set.
- 6,954
- 9,833
Jaybee
Silver Knight of the Realm
- 276
- 33
Gravel
Mr. Poopybutthole
- 39,410
- 129,648
Finally got around to watching the finale. Holy fuck ball this season was awful.
You can try to rationalize the plot all you want, but the dialogue was just terrible. Pizza obviously saw that everyone loved Rust's dialogue in season 1, but he went full blown retard with trying to make witty dialogue. That alone ruined the season. But then you throw on an incredibly convoluted plot and it's painful. The character development was slow and unnecessary.
Really, it's incredibly obvious that he wrote it quickly. He may be a good writer, but not on a timeline.
You can try to rationalize the plot all you want, but the dialogue was just terrible. Pizza obviously saw that everyone loved Rust's dialogue in season 1, but he went full blown retard with trying to make witty dialogue. That alone ruined the season. But then you throw on an incredibly convoluted plot and it's painful. The character development was slow and unnecessary.
Really, it's incredibly obvious that he wrote it quickly. He may be a good writer, but not on a timeline.
- 1
Vandyn
Blackwing Lair Raider
- 3,656
- 1,382
Finally saw the finale. The season as a whole was average. Not horrible but not great. I fully expected all 3 to die so I was slightly surprised McAdams lived (wife thought the girl with the slashed face was going to ambush her on the boat). When the credits finally rolled, it was more of a 'meh' feeling than anything else. Most memorable line of the whole show was 'you can't act for shit', which is saying something about the show as a whole.
Mist
REEEEeyore
- 31,199
- 23,382
Haha, watching it all put together like that makes me appreciate this season as some bizarre meta parody of film noir gangster/detective stories.
Harkon
Vyemm Raider
- 1,549
- 4,090
Yea it feels like he would be better writing and refining amazing scripts for a one off mini-series every few years rather then trying to pump out a yearly series show with a tight timetable.
Like if they had waited even an extra year, refined the script, and released it as another one off mini series that True Detective seemed to be originally, this should could have been fantastic instead of average.
Disagree completely. Even with refinement on the dialogue, this season would have been terrible. The plot itself was completely disjointed and uninteresting. Gang bangers, mafia, and corrupt politicians/businessmen is old hat. The first season was something different: an intriguing story about the bayou, a strange religion, and a serial killer unraveling over a 17 year period. This season felt more like watching a mediocre episode of Law and Order.
- 1
So when does popsicle publish his memoirs about season 2? "My life and times watching Season 2 and all the words I used to express my thoughts on it."
You think his editor would be like, "too many fucking words, man, cut that book in half."
You think his editor would be like, "too many fucking words, man, cut that book in half."